Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless
by alain94040 on Saturday June 25, 2011 @04:19AM
(#2695247)
At a minimum, if you are concerned with a huge tax liability, exercise ONE option. And tell everyone else in your situation to do the same.
It will cost you less than $200, and it will be very annoying to Skype. It takes the same amount of paperwork and lawyer time.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless
by lawnchair_larry on Friday June 24, 2011 @07:39PM
(#2694381)
It's almost like they want you to know that they are raising the price of admission to even challenge them to a fight.
Pure evil.
My sympathy. I am thinking the tax, as described by them, is not how the IRS would view it. I would imagine that you probably want all this behind you, but I would think a lawyer mightbhave a different interpretation. You would still net zero, but the tax things seems way out of left field.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless
by aphexairlines on Friday June 24, 2011 @09:08PM
(#2694594)
Did you get the feeling before from your time there that they were this kind of people?
This sounds not only terrible but retributive. Did you know this would end this way?
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless
by Daniel_Newby on Saturday June 25, 2011 @02:16AM
(#2695077)
>... demand tax withholding on the shares, valued at fair market value ...
Income tax is only due on the portion of the asset that is not subject to a "substantial risk of forfeiture". Thus a letter claiming certainty of instant forfeiture cannot also claim income tax. (FYI, other limits to property rights, such as a lock-up agreement after an IPO, are not considered a forfeiture.)
So why did they lie to scare you out of doing something that would have been pointless? Because if they had been forced to buy back the stock at the exercise price, they would have had to pay income tax on the difference from the fair market value.
The sum effect of 1 and 2 being net-zero gain on the shares, minus a large chunk of cash out of pocket tied up in a tax withholding account.
Terrible.