Right now, that stuff is done on an ad hoc basis. If Foursquare ends up owning that market, they're going to make a mint. And a) nobody else comes close to owning it, and b) Foursquare is a better implementation than most existing loyalty programs, especially for a new user.
Well, good luck to you and the rest of 4sq. I like you guys, just don't get how you will survive.
There was a smart phone only offer for free popcorn at the movie theater the other day. It was advertised with physical posters all over the theater, directing you to Yahoo for free popcorn. I figured "why not," got out my phone while riding the escalator, got the evil eye from my wife for pulling out my phone in the middle of a conversation, got weirded out by the Facebook requirement, and gave up.
I remain unconvinced that local advertising / coupons is something that is worth using a cell phone for.
Data, by definition, is in the past.
Users' past location data is hugely valuable, just like customer purchase history is valuable for Amazon.
At least Facebook has 'friendships' that can be leveraged as value creating entities for which users go visit the site. 4sq is not even that. I use the app to check in to places, rarely every visiting the site.
Someone please explain to me how is 4sq worth $600M?