News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by gnosis on Friday June 24, 2011 @03:34PM (#2693569)
Please don't use the @name convention on HN.

HN is not youtube, where there's no threading of comments and where it's impossible to divine who you're responding to without the @name.

Here it's quite obvious who you're responding to, because your comment is indented under the comment you've replied to.

Also, while we're at it, replies that say no more than "I agree" or "I disagree" are generally frowned on here, since they're almost completely contentless and don't contribute to the discussion.

Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by dctoedt on Friday June 24, 2011 @03:44PM (#2693606)
> Here it's quite obvious who you're responding to, because your comment is indented under the comment you've replied to.

Right now that's indeed true. If later on there were to be a lot of intervening comments, it'd be more difficult to tell immediately who the response was directed to. In that case, the @name convention likely would be helpful to readers.

> Also, while we're at it, replies that say no more than "I agree" or "I disagree" are generally frowned on here, since they're almost completely contentless and don't contribute to the discussion.

That's certainly true in the general case, when you have a random third party chiming in with his or her agreement.

In this case, though, the "I agree" was a useful clarification: It signaled, to someone who had responded to me with what could be interpreted as a challenge, that we were on the same page.

Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by kwantam on Friday June 24, 2011 @04:02PM (#2693657)

    > Right now that's indeed true. If later on there were to be
    > a lot of intervening comments, it'd be more difficult to
    > tell immediately who the response was directed to.
Not really. Making relationships between messages clear is kind of the point of tree-structured comments.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by cshesse on Friday June 24, 2011 @04:44PM (#2693786)
It is the point, but it doesn't always work. I have had to use my mouse to record the current level of indentation and then scroll up to find the parent post on some sites.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by beagle3 on Saturday June 25, 2011 @03:24AM (#2695168)
But you do remember who said what without scrolling, even if it is 3 screens up? (do you even care WHO said it at all or just what was said?)

Also "use my mouse to record the level of indention" is wrong. It is perfectly visual.

"On some sites" - maybe, but not on HN. And we're discussing (on HN) a comment made on HN.

To me, your argument makes no sense and looks like a rationalization of "damn it, I'm used to seeing this style, and I'm going to find an excuse to use it on HN whether it makes sense or not"

Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by mgkimsal on Friday June 24, 2011 @05:23PM (#2693939)
When the leaves in the tree move around (or disappear) based on points/scoring/etc, it's still harder to parse than something like slashdot where the positions don't change.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by bostonvaulter2 on Saturday June 25, 2011 @03:45AM (#2695197)
The parent child relationships never disappear.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by shmageggy on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:48PM (#2694550)
He omitted the word "tech" in his quote, implying the statement should apply to all employees. That's minimal, but he is saying something.
Re:Skype options turn out to be worthless by strlen on Friday June 24, 2011 @05:23PM (#2693938)
@gnosis I disagree