If I used a password manager, it would have to be on an airgapped and password protected system, making it essentially useless for me. For me, it’s easier to memorize a password/salting algorithm that generates unique passwords to the website or service I’m using, so that I don’t have to actually memorize any passwords—only the algorithm.
I also invite you to read my response above to someone else regarding the security of such an algorithm: with some examples, brute forcing an algorithm is easier than brute forcing a master password.
I'd argue even those who think they do probably don't.
To me the whole conversation sounds like this:
- An unknown, low security bank was broken into.
- This proves storing your money in a bank is a terrible idea! This is why I keep all my money in my home.
- No that's definitely a worse idea. Storing your money in a bank is the most secure way to keep your money. It's not infallible but-
- Yes but alone i don't have that much money... It's a lot more attractive if it's in a big oot everybody else's.
- Well no, most good banks invest a lot more in security than you ever would or could.
- No it's okay, because I put it in a box and I have a lock on it.
- Like a safe?
- No. I don't trust safes either.
You will never be one thousandth as good at securing hundreds of password as the most robust tools we have today. You may be good at remembering a couple of long, random passphrases. You can use those as a master password / encryption key.
The software mentioned in the article is not a particularly good or trustworthy password manager, so no it doesn't make sense to put it in the same lot as the actually-good ones.
Or to put it another way, if I come up with a crappy off brand version control software and backdoor it, that doesn't reflect badly on VCS, it reflects badly on me.