Re:All anti-virus have failed
by geofft on Saturday April 24, 2021 @03:22AM
(#26922979)
Does any large/important installation actually rely on antivirus for their security posture? My impression is that if you're at the point of having to detect malicious code, you've already failed, and most large companies that run antivirus only do so because it's required by years-old compliance standards.
Re:All anti-virus have failed
by nexuist on Saturday April 24, 2021 @03:57AM
(#26923137)
Antivirus has always been the wrong solution to this problem. Mobile computing showed us the way: sandboxed applications with the operating system asking the user for consent before exposing any new APIs to the application.
The fact that any arbitrary program executed on Windows can still wipe out your entire user folder without any sort of warning or request for permission is astounding to me. There's probably a million different (unsecured) ways to bork the install too, so that your computer won't boot the next time it restarts. And let's not forget our best friend, ransomware, whose singular reason for existing is the lack of filesystem controls.
Re:All anti-virus have failed
by jorangreef on Saturday April 24, 2021 @04:56AM
(#26923421)
Sandboxes can still be dirtied, and would not have stopped the recent Apple Mail zero-day.
For that you need static analysis on file formats, but this is a recent technique and not something that scanners have historically been good at (e.g. Moxie's recent reverse file format strike on Cellebrite).
Nevertheless, it comes down to defense-in-depth. There's no silver bullet.
The fact that any arbitrary program executed on Windows can still wipe out your entire user folder without any sort of warning or request for permission is astounding to me. There's probably a million different (unsecured) ways to bork the install too, so that your computer won't boot the next time it restarts. And let's not forget our best friend, ransomware, whose singular reason for existing is the lack of filesystem controls.
For that you need static analysis on file formats, but this is a recent technique and not something that scanners have historically been good at (e.g. Moxie's recent reverse file format strike on Cellebrite).
Nevertheless, it comes down to defense-in-depth. There's no silver bullet.