News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by Ar-Curunir on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:45PM (#26921034)
So, are trans folks immoral? Organ transplants? Prosthetics? Where do you draw the line?
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by Edman274 on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:32PM (#26921395)
It would absolutely be immoral to genetically engineer a human to be born so that their gender identity and their biological form don't match. It would absolutely be immoral to genetically engineer a human so that they need to have organ transplants. It would absolutely be immoral to have scientists in the lab spend years doing research on how to create a human being that will be born needing to use a prosthetic leg.

I don't think anyone is saying that if a fucking Frankenstein's monster human/monkey hybrid were engineered, that people would say that the chimera itself had committed an immoral act. They would say that it was wrong to make that thing. You don't even understand what point you're trying to make.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by brbsix on Friday April 23, 2021 @10:58PM (#26921880)
If the technology were readily accessible to conceive what could be referred to as a "super human" (without genetic disorder, resistance to disease, no predisposition for mental illness, superior athletic ability, high IQ), would it absolutely be immoral to conceive a human being via an entirely natural process?

If it is absolutely immoral to genetically engineer a human being that would require an organ transplant then it would seemingly also be immoral to not utilize readily accessible technology that could have prevented such a disorder, no?

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by Edman274 on Saturday April 24, 2021 @12:50AM (#26922331)
>"If it is absolutely immoral to genetically engineer a human being that would require an organ transplant then it would seemingly also be immoral to not utilize readily accessible technology that could have prevented such a disorder, no?"

Well, actually, no - that doesn't necessarily follow. It's not valid to say "if it's wrong to do x then it's wrong to not do things that prevent x" - you can substitute X for plenty of other things. It's wrong for me to steal money from a friend, but it doesn't logically follow that I'm morally obligated to buy a security system for my friend so he doesn't get stolen from. The analogy is kind of funky here, but I think you get what I'm saying.

There's an intentionality that exists with genetic engineering that doesn't exist with people having kids the old-fashioned way. If someone has a child, and that child turns out to have a birth defect that causes issues, that's a sad accident most of the time, and accidents don't have the same moral quality as intentional acts, like genetically engineering someone.

Let's not lose track of why this came up. The question was "So, are trans folks immoral? Organ transplants? Prosthetics? Where do you draw the line?" and that was in response to "It is immoral to create something sentient which has not been created by natural processes. To bring a sentient being into the world which is created by human engineering process is immoral because there are no guarantees that we do not create something which is horribly mutated, fucked up genetically, and experiences only pain for its entire life."

Asking if we're morally obligated to try to make super babies is a distraction from that earlier question. I said what I did not because I wanted to argue for or against the validity of eugenics, but because I wanted to call attention to how absurd the line of reasoning was.

The person commenting thought that they hit on a pretty solid point when they seemed to equivocate scientists making human-monkey chimeras with people that have to use a fucking cane. I pointed out that no one is intentionally genetically engineering people to force them to have to use canes, and then you've come along to say that if it's possible to ensure that someone will be born without having to use a cane, then they're morally obligated to do that. Somewhere we went off the rails, huh?

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by chacha2 on Saturday April 24, 2021 @10:55AM (#26925291)
> no predisposition for mental illness,[...] high IQ

Already you've delved into ideology.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by deertick1 on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:14PM (#26921260)
Are trans folks immoral : No I don't care what someone choses to do with their own body, that's their business.

Organ transplants :

No, this is a life saving (or condition improving) medical procedure. Same for prosthetics.

I am referring only to experiments where the outcome might be the creation of a new species of sentient being. Pretty much I'm drawing the line at exactly the posted experiment.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by rootusrootus on Friday April 23, 2021 @09:12PM (#26921246)
While I'm not sure I entirely agree with the point OP made, it's pretty clear that 'creating a sentient being' is the line being crossed. Modding a being already in existence is not at all comparable.
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by slumdev on Friday April 23, 2021 @10:35PM (#26921756)
> So, are trans folks immoral?

Yes.

> Organ transplants?

OK, as long as they were taken from someone who was actually dead. Not all organs can be taken after death. In these cases, the transplant surgeon ends the donor's life in the process of harvesting.

> Prosthetics?

OK.

Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by kaba0 on Saturday April 24, 2021 @04:01AM (#26923156)
Is biological death the same as clinical one? Should someone be resurrected?
Re:Human-monkey chimera embryos created in lab by slumdev on Saturday April 24, 2021 @09:17AM (#26924651)
Death is irreversible, but our understanding of it keeps improving.

At one point, pulmonary arrest was considered death. Then, cardiac arrest. Now, we use the cessation of brain activity as an approximation, but there have been plenty of cases of patients with zero brain activity making full recoveries.

The best definition of death is probably information-theoretic death. But that's not something we know how to measure (yet), so the organ harvests continue:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information-theoretic_death