News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who killed the netbook? by nextparadigms on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:40AM (#2691939)
The problem with netbooks is they are very slow with Windows on them and most of them still cost $500. For most people a tablet would offer a much better experience overall for surfing the web.

But I think we'll start seeing a lot of ARM based slim netbooks/low-end notebooks with quad core 1.5 Ghz Tegra 3 chips that will cost under $250-$300 with either Chrome OS or Android, that will fulfill the netbook's purpose of surfing the web very well for that price. I think a lot of people would still prefer a machine that is half the price of iPad and has a real keyboard, for surfing the web, and that will seem very fast, at least compared to an Atom running under Windows 7.

I didn't read the article, but was he suggesting it was the Macbook Air that killed the netbook? I think that's ridiculous. A macbook air is what $1000-$1400? It wouldn't even be on most people's radar when looking for a cheap mobile computer they can surf the web on.

Re:Who killed the netbook? by todayiamme on Friday June 24, 2011 @09:20AM (#2692058)
>>> didn't read the article, but was he suggesting it was the Macbook Air that killed the netbook? <<<

I'm sorry if this is rude, but I downvoted you. I did that because you didn't bother to read the article, but you bothered to comment.

It's just isn't that simple. His argument for the MacBook Air is that it's in the same form factor, while having incredible battery life and being more powerful computationally. Plus, throw in OS X and you have a deal. In a way Air is netbook inspired in terms of the form factor, and the it killed the netbook by making the point that you could still pack in impressive features into a form factor that small by conventional standards, while having a decent profit margin.

In the article, the author makes the point that what really killed the netbook was portable computing (in the form of smart phones and tablets) that packed the same punch and was more intuitive, while maintaining a good enough profit margin for hardware manufacturers to stampede in order to get into the segment.

That said, I have a netbook, an Acer Aspire One, and it runs Ubuntu 10.10 with a grin and is quite awesome once you get used to the tiny keyboard...

Besides, I really do think that no one is taking real advantage of modern computing and you can still write Ruby code on Pentium 2 era PC once you flash it and boil it down to the basics. I think that if someone is dedicated then even a dumb terminal is enough to write code, why do you need that new found computational power? This really is an honest question.

Re:Who killed the netbook? by kijinbear on Friday June 24, 2011 @10:01AM (#2692217)
I completely agree with the author's argument about smartphones and tablets, but I think @nextparadigms is right about the MacBook Air. It belongs in a completely different market segment, along with $2,000 "ultraportables" from Lenovo and Toshiba. That segment has been there for a long time even before netbooks appeared.

It's definitely possible to pack a real Core 2 or i7 processor, an optical drive, and 10+ hours of battery life in a 11-13 inch form factor with a weight of no more than 3 pounds. It gets pretty damn expensive, though, even without the mandatory Apple mark-up.

Personally, I would urge anyone who has a good enough budget to get a real ultraportable instead of a half-assed Atom netbook. But if somebody is shopping for a $350 netbook, I don't think they'd consider the MacBook Air a serious alternative. If anything, smartphones and tablets are stealing market share from both netbooks and ultraportables.

Re:Who killed the netbook? by todayiamme on Friday June 24, 2011 @10:34AM (#2692362)
I think that the author was talking about functionality...

>>> If there was an appetite for easy-to-use, lightweight, entertainment and light computing devices, the netbook was supposed help fulfill that dream. Instead, it's been replaced in functionality by lower priced computers (a version of the MacBook Air became available for $995) having more capacity and better specs than the OLPC—while retaining light weight, high battery power conservation, and SSD devices without a plethora of jacks and an integral DVD drive—and the smartphone and pad/tablet genre. <<<

Re:Who killed the netbook? by kijinbear on Friday June 24, 2011 @12:14PM (#2692743)
Being "replaced in functionality" by a superior product that costs at least 3 times as much doesn't make the inferior product "dead" any more than BMW makes Ford "dead". The author makes some good points, but the MacBook Air is a bad example.
Re:Who killed the netbook? by todayiamme on Friday June 24, 2011 @11:04PM (#2694813)
Ah yes, you're right.

Thank you for correcting me.

Re:Who killed the netbook? by Goladus on Friday June 24, 2011 @09:57AM (#2692201)
I downvoted your post because the second sentence attacks the poster rather than the post. It is impossible to you to know for sure whether someone read an article or not before posting. Such a guess never adds anything to a discussion. It is always possible to address flaws in a post without accusing the author of not reading something.
Re:Who killed the netbook? by todayiamme on Friday June 24, 2011 @10:29AM (#2692339)
I'm sorry if it sounds like I was attacking him, but I actually didn't mean to.

The author admitted that he hadn't read the post...

P.S. - I'm a she not a he...

Re:Who killed the netbook? by Goladus on Saturday June 25, 2011 @06:21PM (#2696746)
Yeah my mistake there, sorry.
Re:Who killed the netbook? by bryanlarsen on Friday June 24, 2011 @10:03AM (#2692230)
He didn't guess. nextparadigms admitted that he didn't read the article.
Re:Who killed the netbook? by Vvector on Friday June 24, 2011 @09:59AM (#2692208)
"[The Mackbook Air] wouldn't even be on most people's radar when looking for a cheap mobile computer they can surf the web on."

The article suggests that netbooks have three primary features: lightweight, low price, long battery life. The MB Air nails two of those, and works for consumers that don't mind the extra price. For those who are price sensitive, netbooks have been attacked on the bottom front by tablets and smartphones.

Re:Who killed the netbook? by pyre on Friday June 24, 2011 @11:07AM (#2692489)
There are netbooks with 9-14 hours of battery life. How does 6 hours of battery life 'nail it' in comparison?
Re:Who killed the netbook? by GFischer on Friday June 24, 2011 @09:09AM (#2692025)
Are they really that expensive in the U.S.? I expected them to be cheaper than here in Uruguay, where an Atom-based netbook sells from U$ 300 to U$ 500.

And, Windows 7 or XP netbooks offer a very good web surfing experience (both my girlfriend and my mother-in-law are very pleased).