News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'World’s most powerful' tidal turbine sets sail from Dundee by ggm on Friday April 23, 2021 @04:01PM (#26918580)
If tidal or wave had been viable i think by now the offshore oil industry would have been exploiting it at their installations.

For contrast, some of the fastest deployments of autonomous vehicles, solar energy and novel digital communications come at Australian remote mine sites.

I badly wanted to read takedowns of your summary, but I'm forced to say absent well constructed arguments of viability i think you're carrying the room. Obviously the backers, grant or seed capital aided believe in what they're doing and we're a long way down the road from Salter's ducks. But on balance I think this is a niche product.

Some places like the bay of fundy, if you took local ecology out of the picture, look like 80% of the construction cost of a tidal race is done for you by nature. It doesn't mean they would work, it only means the initial capital investment might be better. I think the same is true of the Scots waterways used for these tests, but the volume of power remains below wind and you would be right to say it questions why the investment given the balance of returns.

The same is true of Carbon Capture and Storage: huge but elusive upside for the coal power sector, exploiting something known to work, from gas and oil well injection. It's had billions pumped in (hah) worldwide and doesn't seem to work in practice. Fugitive gas is a problem and the chemistry is complex and consumes energy ferociously to do the conversions. Had the same funds been spent on battery tech, improvements in transmission and other change to power, we'd be significantly better off (in australia)

(Not an engineer, not in the power sector)

There are no comments on this comment yet.