News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by ChuckMcM on Friday June 24, 2011 @02:14AM (#2691224)
I will say this for these folks, they seem to have gone 'all in.'

One of the interesting thing about politics is how hard it is to change things. To get a bill passed or an amendment added you need to get other politicians on your side, you need a compelling plan, and then you need lots of follow through. Controversy is to politics like energy is to chemical reactions. The more controversy you have around it increases the 'energy' level, more politicians are willing to commit to a vote because some of their constituents are telling the 'you gotta do something about ...'

The actions of these guys and wikileaks and anonymous are feeding a lot of energy into this system. I listened to a presentation by the East-West Institute [1] which was attempting to harness stuff like this to make 'cyber terrorism' a national issue.

Groups like this take the energy that is out there and channel it into "policy workshops" which are really nothing more than telling the politicians that if they follow their recommendations it will address this growing need. They feed off this stuff. Nobody listens to you if they don't think there are any issues that need addressing (the old "Everything is fine! Why change anything?" dilemma).

The truly fascinating thing about this is there was a great analysis on terrorist groups and whether or not they ever achieved their stated goals [2]. Basically terrorists who don't have a special interest group or political action committee (PAC) in place to harness the energy created by the terrorist acts for durable change are unsuccessful at making any change. Instead the energy they produce, the ability for the political system to make changes, is harnessed by others to make the changes that these other people want to make instead.

Its a weird thing but when you look at how it has been done by PACs and SIGs it can be really enlightening. Its like security theater at the airport, everyone (even the people who do it), know that it does nothing to actually make people safer on planes. However what it does do is give another person their own mini-military unit (DHS) and a way to influence things.

This happens on the small scale too, some horrible thing will happen due to some highly random event or events, and it causes great public sympathy and outcry. Someone comes along and taps that energy, promises it will "never happen again" if you do what they say, and they aren't really lying, the odds of that thing happening again could be extremely remote.

To use a current example, people who are proposing their gear by installed in nuclear plants so that the next time a 9.0 quake + 40' tsunami hits the plant will be safe. Since the likelyhood of another 9.x quake + Tsunami happening again in our or even our grandchildren's lifetime is effectively 0 they could do anything and claim victory. Sell special "Tsunami resistant latex paint" which if you coat a building with this the water will go around instead. Its a crazy claim but someone will buy into "this will make the bad thing not happen again" and guess what? It doesn't happen again because the chance of it happening is so close to zero.

Lulz here is dumping huge amounts of energy into the system. I don't see any 'good' guys lobbying effectively for tapping that to make for better network security or IT systems. I do see people like the DHS saying the need a budget appropriation of 50M$ to staff up a new department of expert counter-hackers to mitigate this new threat.

When people with money say "We have to do something!" there will always be people who stand up and offer to do something in exchange for their money.

[1] http://www.ewi.info/

[2] http://english.safe-democracy.org/causes/

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by Alex3917 on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:27AM (#2691903)
"Basically terrorists who don't have a special interest group or political action committee (PAC) in place to harness the energy created by the terrorist acts for durable change are unsuccessful at making any change."

The guy who wired the lead 9/11 hijacker 100k, presumably to pay for the 9/11 attacks, had breakfast with the Bush administration the morning of 9/11. If that isn't access then what is?

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by 3pt14159 on Friday June 24, 2011 @10:01AM (#2692215)
Do you have a reliable source for that?
Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by Alex3917 on Friday June 24, 2011 @10:14AM (#2692274)
It was reported in basically every major newspaper. The Times of India discovered a wire transfer of 100k from the head of Pakistani intelligence (Mahmood Ahmed) to the lead hijacker (Mohamed Atta) shortly before 9/11, and then papers like the NYT/WSJ confirmed the findings with unnamed senior US officials. The US then pressured Pakistan to get Mahmud Ahmed to step down from the ISI, which he did. (Despite being covered in virtually every major newspaper worldwide, none of this was even mentioned by the 9/11 commission report.) If you Google it there are dozens of writeups analyzing the evidence, here is one below chosen mostly at random, along with his Wikipedia article:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahmud_Ahmed#Removal_from_ISI

http://kkak.typepad.com/blog/2011/05/death-of-bin-laden-may-...

The kicker is that Ahmed had breakfast with almost all of the senior Bush administration the day before, the day of, and the two days after 9/11. He actually watched the attacks on TV with Porter Goss and Bob Graham.

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by e40 on Friday June 24, 2011 @06:03PM (#2694092)
The first link's reference is a dead link.

The second link doesn't really have references that are credible.

I'll repeat: anything reliable?

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by Alex3917 on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:27PM (#2694497)
The first link isn't dead, it just has an extra quote at the end of the URL:

http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2001-10-09/india...

There are also footnotes here sourcing all of the claims to major newspapers:

http://www.globalresearch.ca/articles/CHO206A.html

I haven't actually gone to the library and looked up the paper editions or the original broadcasts, but I have no reason to believe that they don't exist. E.g.

"As to September 11th, federal authorities have told ABC News they have now tracked more than $100,000 from banks in Pakistan, to two banks in Florida, to accounts held by suspected hijack ring leader, Mohammed Atta." Source: Statement of Brian Ross reporting on information conveyed to him by the FBI, ABC News, This Week, September 30, 2001.

You might even be able to find this on archive.org, otherwise you'd have to go to a library I guess. I think that Loose Change: Final Cut also sources the claims, but I haven't seen it in a couple years so I can't remember.

edit: Even the sites purporting to debunk the claim don't deny the articles exist, they're just challenging the existence/validity of the anonymous senior official(s).

edit2: Loose Change link showing the government redacted a question about the ISI from the official transcripts of a press conference even though it was asked on video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8IqZwl3l-o#t=1m14s

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by e40 on Sunday June 26, 2011 @04:19PM (#2698973)
The first link isn't dead, it just has an extra quote at the end of the URL

It was dead because it was non-functioning. OK, so the fixed link is good and doesn't backup your assertion:

The guy who wired the lead 9/11 hijacker 100k, presumably to pay for the 9/11 attacks, had breakfast with the Bush administration the morning of 9/11.

That's what people here are asking for a "reliable source" for. And Loose Change would not be considered a reliable source.

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by Produce on Friday June 24, 2011 @11:40AM (#2692593)
To simplify the argument you presented - 'they need to use the system while simultaneously attacking it'. This makes the assumption that they want to preserve and modify the current system as opposed to outright decimating it. One way of framing their campaign is that they are basically doing what the Allies did to the Nazis, which is to say, bombing without restraint in the hopes of leaving nothing but a pile of rubble where they currently stand. I'm also not entirely sure that they are on the side of the people but more that they are simply against the regime.

This makes some sense because, as they say, and I'm paraphrasing here, you can paint shit gold but it's still the same shit. If a century of playing by their rules has brought us no closer to resolving the corruption then its not far-fetched to say that the playing field is skewed by it's very nature.

Disclaimer: I don't advocate this approach but I agree with the general assessment of the situation. Personally, I think that it would be more effective to go Gandhi on their asses.

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by ChuckMcM on Friday June 24, 2011 @12:38PM (#2692860)
Without getting into deep political theory here, you realize that the US system at least has built in mechanisms which allow it to be completely replaced right?

I understand how some people are frustrated by what seems like an unchangeable system (not saying that you are, just an example) when in fact it is quite changeable. If you have the time and energy to learn how to 'politic' changing the system becomes a question of scale much like if you understand how compilers are built changing GCC becomes a question of scale. New system call interface for an embedded architecture? Pretty straight forward. Changing operator precedence and making integers 37 bits long? A harder thing (still doable, its just code, but the scale is larger because you touch more of the code in the compiler).

So to put your comment in 'tech' terms and continuing my gcc analogy, you posit that the goal isn't to change the compiler since that is too hard, rather delete every copy of the source code everywhere and every executable so that folks will have write a new gcc/binutils from scratch. That way the new compiler and binutils will be better than what we have today.

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by devijvers on Friday June 24, 2011 @02:31AM (#2691265)
I agree with you on the energy balance thing, I don't agree Lulz is creating that energy.

What we're seeing is the consequence of letting docs you want to keep a secret out. Lulz is just fishing and reporting what they caught.

To the people who want to revoke more of our liberties for what is basically lousy security: I wish you good luck.

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by StavrosK on Friday June 24, 2011 @07:25AM (#2691784)
What does this matter? They'll both revoke our liberties and not improve security. All that matters is that Joe Sixpack will think "oh my god, hackers will get my money".
Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by lhnz on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:16AM (#2691878)
When this happens and lulzsec or others are still continually proving that nothing has worked because the original security problems still existed, will Joe Sixpack be blind to this?
Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by DuncanIdaho on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:33AM (#2691918)
You (e.g. the government and its cronies) start screaming - we need more control for your security! They are coming for your beer! These hackers are trying to take away your refrigerator!

And Joe Sixpack will gladly turn over any liberties he has.

Just like with TSA. Joe Sixpack obviously couldn't care less. He doesn't care that it is costing him insane amounts of money, he doesn't care that security doesn't really work. He doesn't care about body scanners. Hell I bet that if TSA went and mandated that a random passengers need provide anal relief to TSA agents - JSP would not really care. Because he is a true patriot(tm).

All you need to do is to perform a Jedi mind trick: "You feel safer now."

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by StavrosK on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:52AM (#2691968)
Measures not working? It's obvious: We need more measures. LulzSec stop their antics due to some unrelated coincidence? The measures work, let's make sure nobody hacks again by instituting more measures!

How many terrorist attacks on airplanes have there been since 9/11? Are measures getting stricter or looser?

Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by verroq on Friday June 24, 2011 @07:24AM (#2691783)
Funnily enough, Australia is creating their elite counter-hacker team at http://www.dsd.gov.au/. They are accepting applications.
Re:LulzSec releases trove of AZ law enforcement documents by podperson on Friday June 24, 2011 @09:09AM (#2692023)
If it's like previous Australian anti-crime task forces they'll only hire people with a proven record of failure.