News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by dekhn on Thursday April 22, 2021 @12:58PM (#26905024)
They put a weight on the wheel to actively defeat the countermeasures. At best you can say that Tesla didn't do a good enough job by using multiple signals to determine driver occupancy and attention. Beyond that, this is just obvious.
Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by Hiopl on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:17PM (#26906034)
As a member of the general public, I absolutely believe it's on Tesla to ensure that their cars can't be tricked into driving completely without driver supervision.

I don't understand why you or others think it's fine just because somebody found a trivial way to defeat their checks. This is a severe public safety issue, since it's not just putting the occupants at risk.

Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by atat7024 on Friday April 23, 2021 @12:12PM (#26916229)
> I absolutely believe it's on Tesla to ensure that their cars can't be tricked into driving completely without driver supervision

Do you also believe it's up to publishers to control how their cryptography libraries are used, and firearms manufacturers to predetermine each and every end user that will lay a finger on their products?

Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by elisharobinson on Saturday April 24, 2021 @07:12AM (#26924033)
Are you using logic you know HN doesn't encourage that
Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by jobigoud on Friday April 23, 2021 @03:46AM (#26912154)
Any normal car can be made to drive by itself if you put a weight on the gas pedal... If you are actively trying to circumvent the foolproofing you will always find a way.
Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by camjohnson26 on Friday April 23, 2021 @11:51AM (#26915986)
That car will crash every time though which discourages doing it, the autopilot will only crash occasionally since it attempts to auto steer, which it makes it far more likely to be relied on and abused.
Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by LorenPechtel on Thursday April 22, 2021 @01:50PM (#26905668)
If people are actively trying to defeat the sensors I don't think it's Tesla's fault.
Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by sidibe on Thursday April 22, 2021 @04:40PM (#26907904)
I think probably there shouldn't be a car available to the public that both can't drive safely without close monitoring and also tempts drivers to try this.

Nothing between basic driver's assist and L4. You can argue whether Tesla is in that range but that's definitely what their messaging is.

Re:CR Engineers Show a Tesla Will Drive with No One in the D... by LorenPechtel on Saturday April 24, 2021 @11:42AM (#26925703)
Yup. Level 2 isn't a good idea and level 3 absolutely should not exist. L4 is even marginal--we are seeing problems with jetliners from this. Pilots are so used to flying the automation that when the L4 pukes (or worse, gets confused) they're out of practice and make mistakes flying the plane.

(However, I think the problem with planes *could be* handled by changing the currency definitions. Time spent in L4 shouldn't count towards being current--and I wouldn't count time spent simply cruising at altitude, either. Only time where the pilot actually has to fly, whether simulator or a real bird.)