Re:Ask HN: Legality of Web Scraping User-Submitted Content?
by timcederman on Wednesday August 06, 2008 @05:40PM
(#269036)
Exactly. If all menus were just "BLT, $5", "Hamburger with tomatoes, lettuce, and onions, $6" then you could make the analogy.
However, compare "basic facts" with an example from the menu from my favourite restaurant (www.chachachar.com.au) (and an example of fair use!):
"Eye Fillet Age 28-36 mths old Lean with sweet, clean, toasty flavours
Served with truffled mash potato, salad of grilled pear & pancetta with smoked tomato relish
Hereford sourced from fertile pastures of NSW raised on Cattle Care accredited properties that are managed under stringent quality & environmental systems and are finished on feedlots in Jindalee."
However, compare "basic facts" with an example from the menu from my favourite restaurant (www.chachachar.com.au) (and an example of fair use!):
"Eye Fillet Age 28-36 mths old Lean with sweet, clean, toasty flavours Served with truffled mash potato, salad of grilled pear & pancetta with smoked tomato relish
Hereford sourced from fertile pastures of NSW raised on Cattle Care accredited properties that are managed under stringent quality & environmental systems and are finished on feedlots in Jindalee."