News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by Silhouette on Thursday June 23, 2011 @06:06PM (#2690111)
Am I missing something here?

The author seems pleased with the results, but as an outsider who isn't familiar with his company I see an ad campaign that cost over $1,000, achieved clickthroughs well under 0.1% despite targeting, and does not appear to have resulted in any measurable benefit at all. There are some comments at the end of the article about how Facebook is great for brand awareness, but there doesn't seem to be much evidence of that in the numbers.

If I were looking at ways to spend advertising budget for a new company (oh, wait, I am looking for...) then this seems like a pretty compelling argument for not wasting money on Facebook ads.

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by unshift on Thursday June 23, 2011 @06:36PM (#2690217)
i thought the same thing. i spent a confused minute trying to figure out which units the 20/40 on the google analytics graph represented, given $1100+ in spending.

$250/day and on no day did facebook generate more than 40 hits. i would not consider that a success.

if facebook ads are good for "brand awareness" would it make more sense to use CPM ads with some sort of logo and/or memorable copy? they seem to be a bit cheaper.

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by bane on Thursday June 23, 2011 @07:30PM (#2690349)
Crap, that's terrible performance. We're probably spending $5.00 a day on Google adverts and pulling in about that many clickthroughs.

(checking), yup, we had 83 clickthroughs today and a total cost of $4.09.

CTR is at about 1.18%

(quickly scratches FB off of list of advertising vehicles)

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by kposehn on Thursday June 23, 2011 @07:43PM (#2690386)
FB and Google CTR is like comparing apples and unicorns :)

Typically with FB, you are doing well if you are finding anything near 0.05% CTR. Remember, these are content ads and not paid search.

Paid search you should be hitting 5%+ CTR on your top search keywords (in position 1-2, around 3% for #3 and 2% or less for anything below). On FB, getting an ad with a consistent 0.077% CTR means they are on to something and should keep going.

Don't knock FB off your list of advertising venues though. Each one is different and has a completely different dynamic, approach to users and value proposition. With paid search you bid on user intent through keywords - what they are looking for right now. On Facebook you are bidding on people and trying to get their attention, a big difference :)

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by bane on Thursday June 23, 2011 @09:32PM (#2690604)
With paid search you bid on user intent through keywords - what they are looking for right now. On Facebook you are bidding on people and trying to get their attention, a big difference :)

That's a very important distinction I hadn't really considered. Their method for "targeting" is entirely different.

I wonder which is more effective?

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by kposehn on Friday June 24, 2011 @01:17AM (#2691102)
Well, each has a particular use and place. Typically, if you're selling widget software, you should start first with paid search by bidding on various widget related exact-match keywords. Go for people that are searching right now for your kind of product or service.

Facebook comes in to play when you know the sort of person you want. Their age, interests, location, education, etc. You can bid on them there and appeal to their situation, needs and interests directly. If you are selling XYZ service for race car drivers, you can appeal to people that love racing cars with an article and lead form telling them how XYZ service is highly essential for their profession.

Different approaches but still profitable. We spend about 40% of our monthly budget on search and 60% on Facebook. FB is very good when trying to generate leads that you eventually turn into sales. Paid search is very good when you want someone to take out their wallet and buy right the hell now, but you also will pay far more for that person.

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by mckoss on Friday June 24, 2011 @08:24AM (#2691898)
It isn't clear to me that the users clicking the most popular version of their ad were not more interested in beer than in their product.
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by alain94040 on Friday June 24, 2011 @03:23AM (#2691371)
You got it exactly right. You can see how my numbers added up between Google and Facebook (http://blog.fairsoftware.net/2011/04/01/sell-your-google-sto...). Facebook allows you to attract people who don't know they could use your product (in my case, an entrepreneur conference - when is the last time you googled for a founder conference?). So yes, conversion rates are lower.

I call it discovery vs. intent. Google allows you to capture people's intent. Facebook allows you to let your target demographic discover new products.

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by aisalwaysa on Thursday June 23, 2011 @07:50PM (#2690408)
Which is the Apple and which is the Unicorn?
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by kposehn on Thursday June 23, 2011 @07:58PM (#2690429)
They switch places depending on AdWords QS and FB's approval policies :D
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by Serene on Thursday June 23, 2011 @06:31PM (#2690205)
The average click-through rate for Facebook ads was 0.063% in 2009 and 0.051% in 2010. Click-through rates used to be about 3% in the 90s, but have been declining since. Current industry standard is 0.1%. I heard that facebook is good for awareness, just to let low- or no-paying people know you exist, but click-through rates are pitiful, indeed.
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by kposehn on Thursday June 23, 2011 @07:43PM (#2690389)
CTR has declined since the early days but profitability has really increased. Check out some of the ad management tools if you're having trouble - they can really help you get into the data and find results :)
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by aisalwaysa on Thursday June 23, 2011 @06:19PM (#2690159)
I can really see it going either way. I interpret this to show Facebook Ads are not a good way to get instant ROI. But there is a lot of value in having a large number of Likes because you can market to them each time you release a new product... in SignNow's case, they have 700 interested ears to begin each new adoption cycle now.

Hard to quantify the value of that. My opinion is that it's worth a lot for the early ears, but not if you are thinking short term only.

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by novum on Thursday June 23, 2011 @06:35PM (#2690211)
Facebook calculates an "edge rank" for each piece of content based on metrics such as likes, comments, post time, content type, and so on. Edge rank is used, among other things, to determine the likelihood of a given piece of content appearing in your feed.

Only a fraction of a page's fans will see each update from that page. By some estimates, that number is only 5-10% of a page's fans. So they've earned 700 new fans, but that doesn't mean 700 impressions each time they post.

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by Silhouette on Thursday June 23, 2011 @06:23PM (#2690172)
Fair enough: if getting someone to Like you on Facebook turns out to be one step in a funnel that does convert a significant number of people in the long run, then yes, that has a measurable value.

I think the sceptic in me says that if you didn't get a worthwhile hit from a targeted ad spend, and if the Likers are only a subset of that target market, many of whom didn't even leave Facebook to visit your site, then it's unlikely to give a worthwhile conversion rate down the line either. Maybe the sceptic in me is wrong on this one, but only time will tell...

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by mscarborough on Thursday June 23, 2011 @10:56PM (#2690784)
They mentioned the campaign stopped on the last day of the conference.

Why not let it run for an extra week or three? I don't think demoing new software you learned about during a conference is going to really happen by the last day of said conference.

Also if you did not make an impression on attendees enough to merit an @todo item somewhere, Facebook ads seem kind of futile.

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by mchusma on Friday June 24, 2011 @12:08PM (#2692714)
mscarborough- This was more of an experiment for us, and we didn't want to burn funds indefinitely without understanding the consequence. Also, our best performing ad was a half joke about drinking beer at the conference, although we could have probably come up with some witty "our founders are hung over" type ad.
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by orijing on Friday June 24, 2011 @02:11AM (#2691217)
I don't understand why CTR should matter (except as feedback for whether their ads are performing or not) if they're paying per click (CPC)?
Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by amitagrawal on Friday June 24, 2011 @04:55AM (#2691537)
CTR matters for a couple of important reasons - profits & relevance.

Google, Facebook, Bing, etc use it directly to make more money on the same number of ad impressions.

Let's suppose there are 2 advertisers -

Andy who bids $1/click has 1% CTR & Bob who bids $0.60/click has 2% CTR.

When each of the ads are shown to users, Andy's will receive 1 click whereas Bob's will have twice as many clicks (every 100 times the ads are shown). The network (Google, FB, Bing, etc) will make $1.2 on Bob and $1 on Andy. That's some 20% profit right there without any special effort on the network's part while showing ads that interest more to the users. You only click something that interests you, right?

As you can see Bob, who bids a lot lower makes 20% more profit to the network for the same amount of ad impressions.

The second reason is relevance. One of the easiest ways to gauge it is CTR. Google, for one, places such a high importance on it that it has baked CTR right into determining how much you really pay to get that visitor in the form on Quality Scores. On Google if you increase your QS your ads start costing less and appear in better positions for the same (or lower) cost.

This is simple economics at play. If you see on the individual ad performance screenshot you can see that the ad that received 0.077% CTR has highest - - reach - social reach - connections - clicks and most important the least cost-per-click. Who wouldn't like to get all the benefits for a lower cost?

Re:We Spent $1,138 on Facebook in 6 Days: Numbers and Lesson... by orijing on Saturday June 25, 2011 @12:24AM (#2694914)
I understand that the CTR makes a difference to the network, but I am pointing out that a low CTR doesn't necessarily mean that the advertiser is worse off. It means two things: it means the advertiser's ad is terrible, or the targeting is suboptimal (relative to an ad with higher CTR), and that you are actually getting more impressions per dollar spent.

All else equal, you actually want to pay LESS per impression, given the same number of clicks per dollar (your CPC). Of course, in any well-designed dynamic system, the prices of the auction should reflect the different probabilities of being clicked.