News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by dehrmann on Thursday April 22, 2021 @01:54AM (#26899211)
> He attributes this to the presence of more-infectious variants.

I still think facemasks are selecting for more infectious strains and likely won't be effective enough in a few years unless vaccines bring us to herd immunity fast enough or the virus mutates into something less severe.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Tepix on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:41AM (#26899521)
Where are the studies that your base your assumption upon?
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by dehrmann on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:49AM (#26899568)
Fair question. We've never done this before to this extent, so there just aren't studies, and this is just a hypothesis. It reminded me a lot of antibiotic resistance, though.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by blackoil on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:58AM (#26899631)
None of the virus build resistance to masks. what exactly is the hypothesis? Masks just reduce the transmission rate, so it shouldn't have any correlation with virality. A 10x more viral variant will still be 10x more with masks, just that overall transmission for all variants will be reduced by 90%
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by penteract on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:36AM (#26899873)
I've had thoughts on similar lines to the top level comment, by the following line of reasoning:

In US and Europe, policies and behavior (such as mask-wearing and social distancing) have become stricter as the number of cases rise and more lenient as the number of cases fall. This means that the reproduction number hovers around 1.

If we imagine that R_0 for Covid-19 is 2.0, no measures are taken, and a variant which is twice as infectious appears when there are 10^6 cases (in a population of 10^9), then the variant will have only infected ~10^6 people by the time we have herd immunity (a very rough estimate).

On the other hand, if measures halving the spread rate are imposed when 10^6 cases are reached and the variant appears, then the variant will still spread exponentially while the original strain is curtailed, resulting in most people catching the highly infectious variant.

I have no background in medicine or epidemiology, so I'm keen for people to point out flaws.

Edit: I am not advocating that no measures to stop or slow the spread of Covid should have been taken.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:06AM (#26899294)
Face masks couldn’t be doing that because they don’t work to slow transmission whatsoever. The whole theory of face masks - even before accounting for real world usage - rests on the assumption that the primary transmission mode is respiratory droplets and not aerosols which is not the case. They’re just medical security theater, except worse because they have obvious negatives. I advocate instead for performing rain dances; they’re no less effective but provide a bit of exercise to boot.

Anyway, on a related vein, non-infection-protecting vaccines can do exactly what you’re saying and select for more virulent/pathogenic strains. Take a look: https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jou.... Because all the COVID/19 vaccines do not prevent infection nor transmission (they reduce it but don’t fully block it), our incredibly shortsighted mass vaccination campaign is likely to select for more pathogenic strains. Go science!

> Could some vaccines drive the evolution of more virulent pathogens? Conventional wisdom is that natural selection will remove highly lethal pathogens if host death greatly reduces transmission. Vaccines that keep hosts alive but still allow transmission could thus allow very virulent strains to circulate in a population. Here we show experimentally that immunization of chickens against Marek's disease virus enhances the fitness of more virulent strains, making it possible for hyperpathogenic strains to transmit. Immunity elicited by direct vaccination or by maternal vaccination prolongs host survival but does not prevent infection, viral replication or transmission, thus extending the infectious periods of strains otherwise too lethal to persist. Our data show that anti-disease vaccines that do not prevent transmission can create conditions that promote the emergence of pathogen strains that cause more severe disease in unvaccinated hosts.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by TheRealSteel on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:12AM (#26899330)
This is untrue. There is an overwhelming amount of evidence that masks reduce the spread of Covid.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:15AM (#26899354)
The only RCT ever performed for self infection of SARS-2 in the community failed to reach significance. No RCT of community masking for SARS-2 transmission has ever been done, probably because it’s unfeasible (translation: we’ve constructed an unfalsifiable hypothesis).

Can you point me to a non mechanistic non associative study that demonstrates that face masks work to prevent community transmission of SARS-2?

EDIR: I can’t reply to the child comment about condoms (does HN have a nesting limit?) but suffice to say we only have 1 RCT on SARS-2 so playing the significance game is silly. You can’t point to a single RCT showing an effect because it doesn’t exist. That’s the problem. We’re mandating an intervention that is unproven to work and rests on theoretical assumptions that are now known to be false.

You can go look at non-SARS-2 RCTs if you want but those also look abysmal. For example go read Macintyre’s cluster-randomized controlled trial of cloth masks in healthcare workers. It’s not encouraging.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by peteretep on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:34AM (#26899479)
First you say

> Face masks ... don’t work to slow transmission whatsoever

and when pushed on it, you imply that this is true because there’s been no trial on it, which is not how implication works.

You then also try and suggest the presence of an unfalsifiable hypothesis which you don’t try and explain, and seems suggestive that you don’t know what the term means?

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:55AM (#26899605)
It’s unfalsifiable because it requires studying a whole community and sequencing every SARS-2 infection to attribute “blame” to the source of the infection. That is very difficult to do and that is why such an RCT does not exist. And yet most of the world is performing this intervention anyway.

That’s the brilliance of “my mask protects you”. It’s not feasibly falsifiable. “My mask protects me” is very easy to falsify. That’s why we have one RCT that studied exactly that and failed to reach significance.

Again, the theoretical MoA of masking only makes sense if SARS-2 spreads via respiratory droplets. If it spreads via aerosols, the sub-micron aerosol particles stay aloft for minutes-hours and bypass the comparatively giant holes of the mask with ease. The sightly altered directional flow is largely irrelevant. You can watch any of the many videos of someone vaping with a mask on/off to see what I’m talking about. Imagine that every time you exhale.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by peteretep on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:50AM (#26899989)
> It’s unfalsifiable because ... very difficult to do

That’s not what that means.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by sampo on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:28AM (#26899441)
> The only RCT ever performed for self infection of SARS-2 in the community failed to reach significance.

Do condoms work against sexually transmitted diseases? 5 out of 10 RCT studies reported statistically significant effect. Do condoms work against unwanted pregnancy? 0 out of 4 RCT studies reported statistically significant effect.

https://jech.bmj.com/content/65/2/100

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:57AM (#26899629)
Wow, what an intellectually dishonest description of your citation. It’s looking at interventions to promote condom usage, not condom usage.

Forgive my tone but...just wow.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by sampo on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:55AM (#26900034)
> It’s looking at interventions to promote condom usage, not condom usage.

So is the mentioned mask RCT study. They should be quite comparable.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by mleonhard on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:04AM (#26899678)
Washington [0], Vermont [1], and Maine [2] all got mask mandates last summer. These states have had half the number of cases [3] as other northern-US states.

Masks reduce respiratory disease transmission in hospitals. They work outside of hospitals, too. Covid-19 spreads like any other respiratory disease.

If you don't want to wear a mask, then stay at home. I have the right to participate in society without catching a dangerous disease from you.

If your mask is uncomfortable, then try some different ones. I use masks made by Burlway [4]. They are very soft. They fit my face perfectly and haven't stretched or shrunk. I have 10 of them. I keep clean ones in a drawer near the door. My going out ritual is now "keys mask phone wallet."

[0] https://www.governor.wa.gov/news-media/inslee-announces-stat...

[1] https://vtdigger.org/2020/07/24/scott-orders-mask-mandate/

[2] https://www.newscentermaine.com/article/news/health/coronavi...

[3] https://ig.ft.com/coronavirus-chart/?areasRegional=uswa&area...

[4] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08DXY4TBS

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by xxxxxxx12 on Thursday April 22, 2021 @09:49AM (#26902693)
> I have the right to participate in society without catching a dangerous disease from you.

You're essentially saying that the disabled (illness is a disability) should be excluded from society.

Shun the unclean and diseased?

You have the option of staying inside if you're afraid of mingling with certain people.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by disabled on Thursday April 22, 2021 @01:16PM (#26905249)
No, this individual is stating that no matter what, people (including the disabled) have to go out in society to things like doctor’s appointments. Everyone has the right not to catch a potentially deadly disease.

“Freedom” does not extend to not wearing masks during a pandemic. Your freedom stops when you are a potential asymptomatic/symptomatic spreader of a potentially deadly disease to others.

Therefore, masks should be required for everyone.

Also, I am disabled and I agree with this poster’s comment. It was definitely not ableist at all. It was 100% in support of masks when out in public.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by xxxxxxx12 on Thursday April 22, 2021 @01:38PM (#26905512)
> Your freedom stops when you are a potential asymptomatic/symptomatic spreader of a potentially deadly disease to others.

I guess condoms must be mandated since antibiotic-resistant STIs are almost inevitable right now.

I guess we have to outlaw unprotected sex.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by perl4ever on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:10PM (#26910619)
Is knowingly exposing someone to an STI without their consent in fact uniformly legal everywhere? Have you ever heard of anyone suggesting it be illegal before?

I'm not expressing an opinion here; I'm trying to understand why you would take for granted that everyone thinks such behavior is ok or inevitably legal, setting aside the specific context of COVID and current partisan conflict.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by xxxxxxx12 on Friday April 23, 2021 @11:09AM (#26915500)
What I'm pointing out it is that, whether people acknowledge it or not, they're treating everyone as though they're infected.

So something like masking is required even if someone seems healthy. It's a regime of constant anxiety and latching onto any and every doom scenario.

So with the same logic, we should be assuming every sex partner has an incurable STI. Especially with the emerging threat of antibiotic-resistant strains, the most risk-avoidant with respect to SARS-CoV-2 would only be consistent by likewise being in favor of extreme measures like mandated condoms, quarantining, forced testing, etc. with something like STIs.

I don't agree with this at all - but it's clear that there's a fixation with COVID that doesn't get applied to other large aspects of society.

If we care about people's health - why don't we lock up fat people and force feed them a strict diet until they're a healthy weight? It's hard for me to see anything under the current public health/political regime that wouldn't justify this.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by perl4ever on Friday April 23, 2021 @05:29PM (#26919416)
I guess a lot of people (extrapolating somewhat from myself) feel like wearing a mask when you go in a building other than your home is not extreme nor has it been enforced in an extreme way, contrasting with your hypotheticals.

From what I read on the internet, it's long been a custom in many places in the far east to wear a mask whenever one has or might have the cold or flu or whatever.

At this point, I'm thinking why shouldn't we westerners adopt that, going forward?

It appears that wearing masks drastically reduced flu transmission, which seems logical given that it's much less contagious than covid-19. That presumably saved many lives.

And the common cold is not worth developing an advanced vaccine against, but what would we be losing if we prevent its transmission?

So I don't see why masks are a bad thing even if covid vanished tomorrow. There are so many measures we take to mitigate things that have substantial known and unknown risks, so it's mysterious to me why people are so vehemently against one with no downsides.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by xxxxxxx12 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @11:59AM (#26957705)
> so it's mysterious to me why people are so vehemently against one with no downsides

Humans have millions of years of evolution searing into their DNA the impulse to socialize with other humans.

I think you're underestimating the effect of completely obscuring the face - how people indicate subtle social cues, emote, and communicate.

This ignores that masking is a nuisance, I don't care what other people say: they're virtue-signalling, Stockholm syndrome victims in my opinion.

Breathing fresh air, unabated, is one of the greatest pleasures in life.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:26PM (#26907045)
> Everyone has the right not to catch a potentially deadly disease.

Nobody has this right. This positive right has never existed. And for good reason. It leads to all manner of evils taken to the extreme.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by perl4ever on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:04PM (#26910586)
Some people think that knowingly exposing someone to HIV should be a serious crime (I don't know if it presently is in any jurisdiction; I'm fairly certain there have been attempts to pass such laws at least).

Is this an example of the positive right that you say never existed and leads to all manner of evils?

Do you think the proponents of it are uniformly politically aligned with the people in favor of masks for COVID?

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:51PM (#26910809)
In the context of COVID we’re actually talking about unknowingly exposing someone to a virus. So I don’t think it’s directly comparable.

Anyway, I don’t believe in throwing someone in jail for such an act. Some people do.

But I don’t think that invalidates the point that such a right does not exist, because “spread disease” is a superset of “knowingly spread disease”.

Ironically here in California it is legal to knowingly spread AIDS to someone, because democrats, yet that same political faction thinks that you are responsible if you unknowingly spread COVID-19 to someoen. (As an aside the absurd “infecting Grandma in the grocery store” doesn’t happen anyway because that’s not really where COVID spreads but I digress)

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by claytongulick on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:54AM (#26899600)
The theory behind universal masking rests on early studies which indicated a possibility of asymptomatic spreaders.

This has mostly been falsified in at least one controlled study [1].

The Danish study is the closest thing we have to RCT on masking [2] which found no statistically significant result from universal masking.

Wearing a mask while symptomatic seems like a good idea though, if you're unable to stay home for some reason, though that's good advice for most airborne contagious illnesses. I appreciated the culture of doing this when I was in Japan - if for no other reason than it told me who to keep my distance from.

[1] https://www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4695

[2] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/m20-6817

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by loosescrews on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:59AM (#26899641)
Is there? Please cite sources. (Preferably scientific or scholarly instead of political.)

There is overwhelming evidence that the virus is spread by fine aerosols: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

It is widely reported (and noted in the article above) that cloth masks are not effective against such particulates.

One of the only studies on the topic found that cloth masks were penetrated by ~97% of such particles: https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/5/4/e006577

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by marvel_boy on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:30AM (#26899456)
Not sure. Could you explain what happened to the India-HK flight? [1] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/scores-test-positi...
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by sterlind on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:11AM (#26899322)
we should be pushing for N95 masks to be cheaper and more available. those masks block aerosols when they're properly fitted (and we should make them easier to fit.)
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by nyokodo on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:15AM (#26899355)
> and we should make them easier to fit

Not to mention make versions for unusual face sizes (big and small). I cannot find one large enough for my face.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Tor3 on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:21AM (#26899388)
And my wife can't find ones small enough to fit her face properly. In her home country masks come in all sizes and shapes, in Europe there seems to be only a single size. At least every type I've looked at is the same size as all the others.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Semaphor on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:26AM (#26899420)
I found one with an amazing fit from China that was large enough. Then I googled the name and found out it’s listed under the fake/mislabeled category on the CDC site [0] with filtration efficiency between 8 and 94% (over 2 ten sample test runs):(

[0]: https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/respirators/testing/NonNIOSH...

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by godelmachine on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:22AM (#26899398)
3M N95 9210 should be big enough to cover anyone's face, methinks.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Semaphor on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:29AM (#26899449)
They are also pretty expensive for a single-use product.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by godelmachine on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:52AM (#26899589)
They are but I believe to will protect anyone extremely well.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by loosescrews on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:35AM (#26899489)
I 100% agree that the conversation should shift to how we can get more particulate masks into people's hands. That said, N95 masks are not the gold standard many people claim they are.

N99 and P100 masks typically include a gasket which improves the seal dramatically. They also come with the bonus of filtering substantially more fine particles. Given than the size of the aerosols in question are less than 5 microns and that the ratings are in relation to 0.1 microns, getting a higher rating is probably a good idea.

Even better still is a silicone mask which is trivial to leak test by covering the filter cartridge inlets (negative pressure) or exhaust valve (positive pressure).

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by disabled on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:35AM (#26899490)
PAPRs (powered air purifiying respirators) would be far more effective and efficient, especially on a long-term basis. People who are at risk of becoming severely ill from a respiratory infection (i.e. Pneumovax 23 recipients), especially in the developed world, should be able to have their national/public/private health insurance pay for a PAPR. After the pandemic, this really should be the case. There are also more compact, more convenient, and better designed PAPRs coming out, such as the Optrel Swiss Air [1] and the CleanSpace Halo [2]. Most PAPRs do not require fit tests to ensure the seal, while N95/N99/P100 masks do. The PAPRs I list can easily be adapted, either formally or informally, to have source control (covering of the exhaust valves).

[1] Optrel Swiss Air: https://industrial.optrel.com/fileadmin/optrel/redaktion/pdf...

[2] CleanSpace Halo: https://cleanspacetechnology.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/...

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Tepix on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:44AM (#26899538)
There has been a large push for N95 masks in Germany. They are now mandatory when doing grocery shopping. You're allowed to use a "surgical mask" instead, however. I think those offer few less protection to the wearer.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:13AM (#26899343)
I would love for N95 usage to become more widespread, but that is hampered by the dogmatic clinging to the belief that cloth masks actually work, unfortunately.

Do N95s work for source control though? They certainly do work for self infection but I haven’t personally read any N95 studies on source control so am not sure.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by loosescrews on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:44AM (#26899541)
If cloth masks don't work, they aren't doing much for source control either. They don't magically filter better in one direction than the other.

If everyone was wearing a particulate mask (e.g. N95), source control wouldn't matter as much. Masks with an exhaust valve are significantly more comfortable and comfort is the reason the CDC is currently citing in regard to their recommendation for people not to wear particulate masks.

If your protection plan relies on everyone else doing something complicated correctly, you have already lost. I think controlling the spread of a virus in the general population using source control is not something our species is capable of.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:06AM (#26899690)
To be clear, I agree. I think the whole concept of source control is silly. Actually I’ll go one step further and say I think the whole concept of trying to artificially slow transmission of SARS-2 in the general population is a bad idea period.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by arrrg on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:24AM (#26899408)
Where are you from that FFP2 usage is not common?

Sure, cloth masks were widespread for about a year but by now usage of FFP2 masks is becoming extremely widespread, especially since the supply is by now overwhelming.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:40AM (#26899516)
I live in California. I see maybe 95% cloth masks in public.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by sterlind on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:17AM (#26899363)
the ones without exhalation valves do. the barrier is bidirectional. the ones with valves bypass this which is why those shouldn't be used for source control but are popular for wildfires etc.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:24AM (#26899407)
Thanks. That was my thinking but glad to see it confirmed.

Kind of ironic that you’re not allowed to wear an N95 with an exhale valve, but are encouraged to wear a surgical mask, bandana, cloth mask, or dirty T-shirt, none of which provide any source control.

Again, the elephant in the room is respiratory viruses in general, and SARS-2 in particular, spread via aerosols. Non-N95 face coverings cannot block aerosols. Indeed mask wearing leads to deeper breaths to maintain homeostasis (this has been studied), therefore lead to a greater net volume of air, therefore lead to increased aerosol emission before even accounting for the potential to nebulize large droplets into a shower of tiny aerosol particles. But I digress.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by loosescrews on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:50AM (#26899569)
A surgical mask, bandana, cloth mask, or dirty T-shirt over a particulate mask (e.g. N95) is typically allowed. There are serious benefits to the wearer to having an exhaust valve. Wearing a second, less effective face covering over the particulate mask retains the benefits of the particulate mask and exhaust valve while maintaining the same level of source control as without the particulate mask.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by tempestn on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:25AM (#26899411)
Cloth masks work better than no mask, so they made sense early on when surgical masks couldn't be found. There are certainly better options now though.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:40AM (#26899509)
There is no RCT that shows cloth masks work any better than no mask. You’re relying on mechanistic studies at best (or crappy associative studies).

Masks incur costs; at a minimum you must admit they alter risk appraisal if nothing else.

Anyway, nobody in this thread has addressed the point that masks don’t even work in theory if aerosol transmission is the dominant transmission mode. That’s before accounting for the incredible cross contamination and misuse of masks that you see in the community.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by claytongulick on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:59AM (#26899643)
In Texas, the mask mandate has been lifted for weeks.

There has not been a surge of new cases.

Throughout 2020, Broken Bow, OK received millions of tourists, it was the #2 short-term vacation rental destination in the country, according to VRBO.

It's a small town with crowded bars. Very few locals or visitors wore masks.

There was not a significant rise in severe Covid cases, and schools mostly kept masking optional.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Semaphor on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:28AM (#26899437)
In Germany, you are required to use surgical or FFP2/(K)N95 masks (in 2 states surgical ones are not allowed) to enter any store. At least in my city, the majority of people wear FFP2 masks.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by dehrmann on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:36AM (#26899492)
I'm curious why there hasn't been a push for this.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by jtsiskin on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:48AM (#26899564)
That’s study says “Immunity elicited by direct vaccination or by maternal vaccination prolongs host survival but does not prevent infection, viral replication or transmission, thus extending the infectious periods of strains otherwise too lethal to persist.”

Is this your concern with the covid vaccine? That a strain which would have killed someone unvaccinated, that person will now instead stay alive and spread it?

The viruses used and discussed in that study had between a 60% and 100% fatality rate. This is pretty different than covid 19

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:02AM (#26899667)
Right but imagine the same study but performed on 1 billion people for a much less lethal virus. That’s what we’re doing with this mass global vaccination campaign.

So yes, that is my concern. But I mainly mention it because it’s a handy counter to the utilitarian collectivist argumentation without having to argue against the ethics of collectivism itself.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by dxdm on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:36AM (#26899494)
Dear internet stranger, do you have any credible citations to back up your claims about the effectiveness of masks?
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:49AM (#26899565)
https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/m20-6817 - Only community RCT of masking for SARS-2 ever performed. Failed to reach significance, bounds are from (in plain english) “slight-moderate worsening” to “moderate+ improvement” in transmission. Endpoint was self infection not source control. No RCT of source control for SARS-2 exists, and yet everyone in this thread besides me is advocating for usage of this unproven intervention, how curious.

https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/5/4/e006577?fbclid=IwAR1eSyc... - cluster-randomized controlled trial of masking in hcw. Compared cloth masking to “standard practice”, not a no-mask control, but results caution against usage of cloth masks due to abysmal filtration efficiency and the increased infections in the group relative to standard practice

I’d have to cite like 10 different studies to show the full story on aerosol transmission and I’m on mobile so I’ll leave that as an exercise to the reader for now. But I’d like someone to at least answer this:

If you take it as fact that SARS-2 primarily spreads through aerosols, what does that imply about the efficacy of masking for source control of SARS-2? There is a reason that the health authorities advocating community usage of masks (which they never did for any respiratory pathogen pre-COVID btw) maintain that SARS-2 spreads through large respiratory droplets. It’s because otherwise the whole concept of community masking is absurd.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by dehrmann on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:01AM (#26899657)
> There is a reason that the health authorities advocating community usage of masks...maintain that SARS-2 spreads through large respiratory droplets. It’s because otherwise the whole concept of community masking is absurd.

But why would they keep saying it? Maybe they are effective. Maybe it's the politician's syllogism. Maybe they're worried that back-peddling would hurt their credibility. Maybe they create enough of a sense of both safety and fear to keep society functioning.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by amanaplanacanal on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:00AM (#26899648)
> If you take it as fact that SARS-2 primarily spreads through aerosols

Is that actually a fact though?

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:09AM (#26899709)
I think a review of the relevant literature shows that it quite obviously is, but I’m about to go to sleep and don’t want to fight that battle thus why I’m trying to direct your attention to the actual point.

So let’s try again:

If you take it as a given that SARS-2 primarily spreads via aerosols, what does that imply about the efficacy of strapping a warm, damp piece of cloth over your breathing holes?

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by mborch on Thursday April 22, 2021 @04:14AM (#26900167)
That masking wearing is virtue signaling, showing that you care. Which is not necessarily a bad thing, but you might as well wear a t-shirt with a message.
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Emphere on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:08AM (#26899702)
What are the obvious negative of face masks?
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:27AM (#26899813)
Worsening acne vulgaris

Worsening rosacea

Difficulty communicating with the hard of hearing, language learners, etc

Reduced ability to convey info via facial expressions

Altered risk appraisal

Having to stand closer or speak louder to convo partner

Psychological discomfort

Bacterial pneumonia

Cross-contamination (hand to mask, mask to hand, hand to face)

Mild negatives from uncomfortable pressure on ears

Sends a message of societal fear that there is something to be afraid of (you might consider this a positive, I don’t personally)

Encourages viewing the wearer as just a vector for disease

Increased CO2 buildup

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Emphere on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:40AM (#26903996)
Your logic is flawed because additive risks like that cannot be compared to exponential risks (like the spread of a virus). There's an asymmetry in the outcomes and the potential upside is enormous; especially when your stated risks are minimal to (say the least), like acne or in some cases, have been proven to be wrong by data (re: psychological "discomfort"--suicide rates decreased last year).
Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @12:52PM (#26904962)
Suicide rates are not the same thing as discomfort.

Calling the risks minimal to acne makes no sense. It’s one of the worst contributors to acne in any person’s daily life.

Even if I agreed with your exponentiality argument the whole point is that I’m saying masks don’t reduce spread. You seem to think there’s only possible upside, but there is equally downside wrt xmission; that is, masks run the risk of worsening transmission.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Emphere on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:27PM (#26910683)
Yes, but they are a pretty good proxy for psychological discomfort levels/rates. And my point was that you can't really compare acne to covid as the latter is much worse (let me emphasize that you _don't_ have to agree with me on this, all you need to agree with is the fact that exponential risk >>>>>>> additive).

Furthermore, there is nothing to suggest that masks run the risk of worsening transmission. I see from your other comments that you're familiar with the mask clinical trials (presumably you're referring to the Danish study). That study was inconclusive (also note that it was _severely_ underpowered), and considering that _nothing_ in our previous knowledge suggests that they worsen infection rates, your reasoning is once again flawed.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by __blockcipher__ on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:55PM (#26910828)
I’ve already outlined in another comment why they could increase transmission.

They increase net volume of air exchanged, therefore all else equal they increase the release of aerosols. There’s furthermore a strong chance that they actively nebulize respiratory droplets into fine aerosols; ie they incresse the relative aerosolization and therefore the absolute aerosols.

They make convo partners stand closer together or speak louder.

They alter risk appraisal.

It is foolish to rule out any downsides. At best you’re advocating for a condom full of holes. At worse you’re advocating for a condom that magically worsens STI transmission.

Re:India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists by Emphere on Friday April 23, 2021 @12:26AM (#26910992)
Nothing in our previous understanding suggests that they increase release of aerosols or aerosolization. Multiple previous studies have shown that they don't (see Asadi, S., Cappa, C.D., Barreda, S. et al. Efficacy of masks and face coverings in controlling outward aerosol particle emission from expiratory activities. Sci Rep 10, 15665 (2020), for one example; there's also older studies but you can look them up yourself).

The other arguments are of the "seatbelts cause more accidents" variety, which honestly aren't worth refuting. But I'll just note that social distancing has much weaker evidence of affecting virus transmission than even masks (there is no real justification for the 6 feet number and mostly unlikely it makes much of a difference). Hell, social distancing is even much more difficult to comply with than wearing masks so your argument makes no sense at all.