Re:DreamWorld (YC W21) MMO raises all red flags
by viraptor on Thursday April 22, 2021 @01:24AM
(#26899057)
It depends where you put a limit on genre. Minecraft for example covers a surprising number of genres using just the basic mechanics + user mods for goals/limitations. Same with Roblox. If you can modify the world, you get them "for free".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:DreamWorld (YC W21) MMO raises all red flags
by woobilicious on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:21AM
(#26899387)
Minecraft wasn't marketed as having "every genre", while showing exactly none in their demo videos.
When you design a game you come up with a core game play loop, Minecraft had this, and notch was competent and humble enough to make his game from scratch, and release a MVP people could play.
This game doesn't have a core game play loop so it hides behind nothing burger statements like this.
Whenever someone makes claims that are both grandiose and vague you should take it with a grain of salt.
But do you know what it does have? it doesn't describe in ambiguities? kickstarter rewards, you get pets, and you get to put your name on a billboard, and the more you donate the bigger your name.
Re:DreamWorld (YC W21) MMO raises all red flags
by viraptor on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:20AM
(#26899770)
I'm not saying they're right, but given we know games can lose the core game play loop and succeed, maybe starting without it isn't a terrible idea. Secondlife is still around without one. Roblox doesn't really have one. Kids can spend hours in Scratch creating their own.