Re:Ask HN: Legality of Web Scraping User-Submitted Content?
by micks56 on Wednesday August 06, 2008 @05:22PM
(#269007)
DMCA safe harbor applies when you are a service provider.
Examples are an ISP that merely provides access to the internet. The ISP cannot be sued for copyright infringement just because infringing bits passed through its servers.
Also, a message board that posts whatever a user writes would obtain DMCA safe harbor. They just provide a service and don't screen out for content. An example is Craigslist.
This person's site DOES NOT enjoy DMCA safe harbor. He scraped the other site and populated his own. He is not even acting as a service provider as the DMCA statute prescribes.
IANAL, but depending on the nature of your service and specifically how the content is collected, you may qualify for DMCA safe harbor protections. This means that if you remove things in a timely manner upon request nobody can sue you. This is how Google caches the whole internet without getting sued.
That's all legal mumbo-jumbo. The real world answer is that some people will get mad regardless of the law, so take their content down and apologize. Follow robots.txt guidelines. Don't post takedown replys a la PirateBay. Generally act sane. If you do all of the above you'll probably be ok.