"Overall, what the evidence shows is that in most ways, smart motorways are as safe as, or safer than, the conventional ones. But not in every way. The statistics suggest that fatal casualty rates are lower while injury rates are slightly higher."
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
Because the purpose of this work is capacity increase, it almost unavoidably increases total fatalities because it increases traffic. If 10% more cars make a journey, even if those journeys aren't made less safe you get 10% more fatal accidents.
UK motorways are some of the safest in the world - alcohol, phones and other distractions, tiredness, driving recklessly are probably more of an issue than smart motorways.
More capacity => More journeys => More fatalities. Dead people aren't dead "per traveller mile" they're just dead.
The government set out knowing they'd kill more people, but rationalising this as acceptable, unsurprisingly it takes a coroner to point out the problem here.
> alcohol, phones and other distractions, tiredness, driving recklessly are probably more of an issue than smart motorways.
Legislation exists to prohibit or mitigate the causes you list. Whereas astonishingly legislation was written to authorize, and indeed fund smart motorways.
This is overly simplistic - it’s not useful to quote “number dead” without considering the quantity.
By just the “number dead” metric, bull fighting or skydiving would be safer than a game of football. It only really makes sense when you consider (deaths from football / games of football played) vs (deaths from bull fights / number of bull fights) which is when we find that bull fights are actually more dangerous!
We could also say the same with surgeries: the more surgeries that are carried out the more deaths by surgery there are, but it doesn’t follow that this means that we should stop doing surgeries.
The total traveller miles in the UK has risen about 10% in the last decade, total accidents have dropped 30%, deaths 20%, despite the killer smart motorway conspiracy
There isn't really a plausible scenario where removing the hard shoulder improves the safety of a motorway. The difference is most likely that smart motorways are bristling with automatic speed cameras and often have lover than normal speed limits applied during any busy period.
(Highways Agency, which was replaced by Highways England, was the very organisation that developed the "Managed Motorways" concept)
The overhead signage warning of problems ahead (until people get used to the fact that they are often left saying something which is no longer relevant), the variable speed limits and the enforcement cameras are the big differences.
This is what the public were led to believe. In practice one of the things revealed by the inquest into one of those deaths was that no one is actually responsible for monitoring those cameras, so marking the lane out of action is on a kind of best efforts basis.
Most recently in January [1] after two stopped vehicles - which would otherwise have stopped on a hard shoulder - instead had to stop in a traffic lane and were hit by a truck.
In principle, smart motorways are already supposed to be covered in cameras etc, so people in a control centre can stop the traffic in a lane if the need arises. Apparently it doesn't work all that well in practice, though.
[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-south-yorkshire-557087...