I think you're correct. His interior function is still just another closure around the original var i.
Also, this feels like piling on, but I think the original (intentionally erroneous) example would print '5' repeatedly rather than '4'. var i ends up with the value 5.
Yes, you are correct (I can't edit right now). You need to return a new function, and a reference actually.
for DOM part, I didn't understand your question. However, the right way to do it is
$(DOMelement:eq(i)).each();
to iterate through each element.
This should work okay:
Also surely DOMelement.eq(i) as opposed to DOMelement:eq(i)?