Previous peak to present might be a less misleading factoid. And that is +20%. Still a big number but less impressive. It may be that confidence in public markets was bolstered by the resilience of the big companies' profits in the face of the virus.
Ok you want a longer period? it’s up nearly 70% from start of 2019, and it’s PE ratio is among the highest in its history.
For what it's worth, a look at the annualized returns chart for the S&P500 might be interesting. https://www.macrotrends.net/2526/sp-500-historical-annual-re... Those green bars on the right don't look tremendously out of place compared to past years. What's really different from previous decades is not the rate of growth but the lack of financial market downturns. Hard to say if that means we're ramping up to "the big one" or if we have fundamentally figured out how to better run the economy so that we have fewer downturns.
A return to March 2020 would be a loss of close to 50%.