News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by gruez on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:09AM (#26862924)
But won't other investors step in and replace them? If a coal power plant can't raise capital from these guys, they'll get it from someone else instead. Failing that, they could offer slightly higher interest rates which will surely attract amoral investors.

edit: Fossil fuel divestment has ‘zero’ climate impact, says Bill Gates (ft.com) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20998948

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by klyrs on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:31AM (#26863153)
The same logic applies to contract killing, doesn't it? If you can't find somebody to take the contract, you can just sweeten the pot until you reach somebody's price, right?

If banks decide to become moral investors and quit the game, the carbon fuel industry will be scrambling to replace about $1T/y in funding. Those shadier investors might be out there with higher interest rates, but I doubt they've got nearly as much to spend. So now carbon production is less profitable, and has less capitol to work with. That would be good.

But the cynic in me says that banks will agree to this, but move to an arms-length model.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by gruez on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:03AM (#26863488)
>The same logic applies to contract killing, doesn't it?

...which is why it's illegal, rather than relying on individuals doing the right thing.

>If banks decide to become moral investors and quit the game, the carbon fuel industry will be scrambling to replace about $1T/y in funding

This only works if enough banks participate. If banks control 50T of capital, and 90% of banks pull out, but fossil fuels only need 1T of funding, then the fossil fuel industry wouldn't be capital constrained. Given the total size of the global capital market ($118T), I find this hard to achieve.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by klyrs on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:28AM (#26863819)
As the biggest players leave, maintaining that level of investment will require the remaining players to concentrate their portfolios into an increasingly unpopular industry. Those investors will price that elevated risk into their offerings, and the result is lower profit margins for the carbon industry. I think this is fully in line with the goals of the movement to divest
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by LatteLazy on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:56AM (#26863417)
>The same logic applies to contract killing, doesn't it?

I don't think anyone expects the rate of contract killing to hit zero just because they personally don't do it...

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by thinkcontext on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:20PM (#26865386)
> If a coal power plant can't raise capital from these guys, they'll get it from someone else instead.

For coal in the US this process has now played itself out enough that there is no longer sufficient value to extract. All of the major players have gone through multiple rounds of bankruptcy where they have shed pension, retiree healthcare, environmental cleanup costs, etc. They are at the point where even the lowest bottom feeders will no longer bid for them. Take for example Blackjewel which was already a bottom feeder holding company for a number of consolidated assets, they went to liquidation because there was no value left.

https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/2021/03/03/blackj...

Of course tax payers will be stuck with the healthcare, pension and cleanup bills, not to mention the underfunded Black Lung Fund and of course all the climate and pollution costs.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by adrianN on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:02AM (#26863480)
Anything that makes investments into fossil fuels more expensive (i.e. higher interest rates), makes investment in carbon neutral technology more attractive.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by thu2111 on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:16AM (#26862983)
"Amoral" or just not convinced by the case made by climatologists for their predictions. Although many try to shut down all discussion of it, there are plenty of rational grounds for suspecting climate change related predictions are incorrect. People who believe that could invest in carbon-emitting industries without any cognitive dissonance or belief that they were being amoral, because they don't believe it's a big deal in the first place. That pushes the decision further downstream to the buyers of the power, and so on. It's a market based solution to making these decisions and weighing the evidence, which incorporates far more people and analysis power than a government department or political party can marshal. So this seems like fair game to me, or at least, preferable to the alternatives.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by adrianN on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:04AM (#26863498)
Literally everyone would be more than happy to hear solid evidence that our climate predictions are wrong. The scientist publishing a solid paper with that conclusion would become a hero.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by thu2111 on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:29PM (#26864629)
It would be nice if that's the case, but do you really think a global community of academics would welcome a paper with open arms that destroyed their entire life's work and careers? Come on. Plenty of papers and analyses have been published showing many wrong predictions and it's had no impact on the field whatsoever.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by thinkcontext on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:28PM (#26865513)
We know from internal documents that over the course of decades the oil majors had their own scientists both review mainstream climate science as well as conduct their own original research and they agreed with the overall mainstream conclusions.

There was also a pretty famous case of a climate skeptic that got funding from Koch to look into things and wound up becoming convinced.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/converted-contrar...

All the oil majors in the world, plus Saudi Arabia, Russia, China, etc have plenty of motivation and resources to poke holes in the theory and have failed to do so. Can you explain why that is?

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by adrianN on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:55PM (#26865001)
Can you cite a couple? There is an exceedingly rich lobby behind fossil fuels. Do you think they wouldn't be happy to sponsor the career of people that prove that their business model isn't killing the climate? Why do you think the scientific consensus is that man made climate change is real and dangerous despite these powerful incentives?
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by thu2111 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:44PM (#26865770)
OK, so there are multiple things to break down here.

Firstly, no such lobby exists anymore, if it ever did. All the supposed oil majors have reinvented themselves as energy companies a long time ago and have big investments in solar, wind, etc. They are well aware that green initiatives aren't going to undermine the oil business any time soon; it will happen on a long enough timescale that they can easily build new businesses and make money from the new tech too. Even if every car factory in the world switched to making electric cars and only electric cars tomorrow, it would take decades for the vehicle fleet to turn over, so there's no real pressure on these people to mount diabolical schemes because the time horizon is far too long.

Secondly, the opposite of "climate change science is unreliable" is not "and therefore there is reliable science saying the opposite". If climatology as a field is unreliable then we are in a knowledge vacuum in which the claims might be true, or they might not be, or they might be some exaggeration of the reality or some over-simplification. All these things are possible if the science is not reliable.

Thirdly, climatology is uniquely difficult to deal with because academic climatologists are the ones producing the actual temperature record itself. There have been arguments in the past about the temperature record because global temperatures didn't follow predictions, at all (e.g. the "pause"), and the response of climatology was to issue new versions of the historical datasets that simply created the trend they had predicted. Sometimes the raw data isn't even available at all, only their adjusted datasets. Thus if climatology is an unreliable field there's actually no way to construct an alternative more reliable narrative, because you'd have to build on datasets controlled by the people you don't trust and which are repeatedly revised to bring data in line with predictions. (they have various justifications for doing so, but the incentive problems created by scientists "fixing" the historical record are obvious enough that they don't need elaboration).

Ideally collection and processing of climate related data would be done by totally different people to those making predictions about it. That doesn't happen: the community is just far too small. So, apparently untrustworthy practices can be pointed out like ... well, like claiming you can accurately predict the temperature a hundred years in advance whilst simultaneously claiming you were unable to accurately measure the actual temperature just ten years ago. But that doesn't then let you say "and so here is a more reliable set of predictions".

At any rate, if you'd like a citation for a reasonable, apparently rational and well argued alternative take, have a look at this talk:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cYZW-6jw98U