News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by kaba0 on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:27AM (#26860282)
> It absolutely does not, and this authors complaint is mirrored in every other review of Gnome 40.

We are either talking about something different, or I don’t know. If you press Super or swipe 3 fingers up you get the preview of every app on every desktop. On the picture in the article, the author has no window open (as apparent from the dock not having any “open” icons)

Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by wander_homer on Monday April 19, 2021 @05:55AM (#26860895)
That's precisely what the author wrote, you just replaced "an extra mouse click" with "press Super or swipe 3 fingers up", hence the additional step to display all running applications still remains with your solution.
Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by kaba0 on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:02AM (#26860940)
And if you do that, then you have every window’s overview there, so what you and the author writes is false.

Would you like a screenshot of it, because that is what I see precisely in front of me?

Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by wander_homer on Monday April 19, 2021 @06:09AM (#26860988)
I don't need a screenshot, I have it running here. By default GNOME does not display all running applications on the desktop, you always have to do an extra step (mouse click, hot corner, key press, swipe) and activate the Activities screen, which is not necessary on basically any other desktop system, and that is precisely what the author complained about.
Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by kaba0 on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:02AM (#26861300)
That’s called not having a taskbar, and has been the case since Gnome 3 (without extensions), so I don’t see how is it relevant under gnome 40.

And why would I want to waste vertical space for that, when I can do a really short movement to see them all, in a better digestible form, because humans are better at remembering the position of something

Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by wander_homer on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:42AM (#26861616)
> That’s called not having a taskbar

Or a dock, the one GNOME already implements in its Activities screen.

> and has been the case since Gnome 3 (without extensions), so I don’t see how is it relevant under gnome 40.

The author never said otherwise, their whole point was to explain, that moving the dock from the left, which is in close range to the hot corner and button to activate the Activities screen, to the bottom, means that you now have to move the mouse a much larger distance if you want to access the dock with the mouse. And since GNOME doesn't support an auto-hiding dock at the bottom, there's no way around that when you use the mouse.

I mean I'm just rephrasing what the author already wrote, because I think they made their point pretty clear to begin with.

> And why would I want to waste vertical space for that, when I can do a really short movement to see them all, in a better digestible form, because humans are better at remembering the position of something

Every other modern and popular desktop on this planet supports auto-hiding docks/panels and nobody asks GNOME to force an always visible dock on you.

Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by unionpivo on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:11AM (#26862348)
Sure, and it has bugged people like me since release of Gnome 3.

Well ... I switched to KDE, so not really bugged by it any more.

What he wrote is factually correct (about extra click/gesture/keypress/...), and complaint of many people.

Re:Gnome 40 – The anti-desktop desktop by 3836293648 on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:27PM (#26866942)
If the author has no windows open and isn't on the overview that's because the author chose to not be on the overview. GNOME boots into the overview now