Re:House Bill for Patent Office Reform Nearly Finished
by tzs on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @05:54PM
(#2685513)
> First to file trumps first to invent? That sounds awful and a step backwards?
How so?
Are you thinking it means that A can invent something, B can see it, and then B can rush to the patent office, get there before A, and get the patent? That's not a problem, because B is not an inventor in this case and is not entitled to a patent.
All first to file really means is that in the case of two independent inventors whose inventions overlap, the patent goes to the one who files first. That person is still subject to all the usual requirements for novelty, utility, non-obvious to one skilled in the prior art (and note that the other inventor's invention might be prior art if it was disclosed).
With first to invent, you have the problem of determining which competing inventor actually invented first--which is often quite subjective (many inventions develop over the course of a long stretch of research, and saying when exactly the inventor actually had the inventive step is not well defined), and involves a lot of interpretation of things like lab notebooks, recollection of discussions, and stuff like that.
First to file is much cleaner--just look at the timestamp on the filing.
How so?
Are you thinking it means that A can invent something, B can see it, and then B can rush to the patent office, get there before A, and get the patent? That's not a problem, because B is not an inventor in this case and is not entitled to a patent.
All first to file really means is that in the case of two independent inventors whose inventions overlap, the patent goes to the one who files first. That person is still subject to all the usual requirements for novelty, utility, non-obvious to one skilled in the prior art (and note that the other inventor's invention might be prior art if it was disclosed).
With first to invent, you have the problem of determining which competing inventor actually invented first--which is often quite subjective (many inventions develop over the course of a long stretch of research, and saying when exactly the inventor actually had the inventive step is not well defined), and involves a lot of interpretation of things like lab notebooks, recollection of discussions, and stuff like that.
First to file is much cleaner--just look at the timestamp on the filing.