Re:Bzg/woof: online monitor for mailing list based patch wor...
by da39a3ee on Sunday April 18, 2021 @01:15PM
(#26854313)
Thanks. Can you explain why that might be a good thing?
If I update the diff, does it become a new reviewable item, independent from the first version?
I've never worked at a large tech company but my understanding is that at e.g. google there is some sort of monorepo, so it would presumably zoom forwards while a commit is under review. Even so, why is it not a good thing to review the commit in an explicit location in the historical commit graph?
Re:Bzg/woof: online monitor for mailing list based patch wor...
by lima on Sunday April 18, 2021 @02:03PM
(#26854783)
Patches would still have a base, it's really more about about the data model. It's possible to synthesize a GitHub PR from a Gerrit CL and vice-versa.
In fact, Gerrit is entirely based on Git and you can simply clone any given CL.
Email is one (very clunky) way of implementing such a workflow, there's other tools like Gerrit, Reviewable or Phabricator that are more friendly.