Re:Ask HN: I bought Voltaren at the chemist, now Google show...
by alisonkisk on Sunday April 18, 2021 @09:43AM
(#26852392)
You may not like the bevahior, butlt there's no indication of dishonesty there. Quite the contrary.
Re:Ask HN: I bought Voltaren at the chemist, now Google show...
by MereInterest on Sunday April 18, 2021 @10:19AM
(#26852684)
If you are referring my my description, then there absolutely is dishonesty. The notice deliberately implies (1) that is is a legal requirement on me to provide a birthday, and (2) that I can disable the use of this information for ad targeting. Neither of these is the case. Therefore, dishonesty.
If you are referring to reading email for ad targeting, you are correct that dishonesty in one area doesn't necessarily imply dishonestly in another. However, it does mean that a person or entity loses the benefit of the doubt, and must have independent verification of their claims.
Oh yeah, and Google frames asking for a birthdate as being "in order to comply with the law". They are deliberately ambiguous in order to imply that it is me who could be breaking the law, rather than Google. Also, the law only requires verifying age, and doesn't require storing the birthdate afterwards. That one is entirely on Google.
So overall, my trust in anything that Google claims is rather low.