Re:GitHub for Mac
by pointlessjon on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @03:04PM
(#2684584)
You argue that spacing produces clutter, but I completely disagree. Clutter is shoving tons of information together without spacing.
You argue that spacing produces clutter
"You argue"?
Clutter means (let me open the dictionary) "a collection of things lying about in an untidy mass".
I never said only spacing produces clutter. Either I'm not explaining myself clearly or you read something that was not in my comment (this is called a strawman, right?)
Re:GitHub for Mac
by pointlessjon on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @05:50PM
(#2685496)
I never said you are completely, objectively wrong. I just disagreed with a point.. On that note, I see nothing untidy.
No hostility meant by "you argue". You provided a critique, an argument. I'd open the dictionary... ;)
You disagreed with the point which I never made ("spacing produces clutter"), putting words into my mouth ("you argue").
You mentioned visual clutter, and then your first bullet point was about too much spacing. Clutter--according to the OS X dictionary you cited earlier--refers to a jumble or tangle of items, implying that they are close together. That's the discrepancy he was referring to.
His posts were completely non-hostile, so aren't you overreacting?
You come off as far more angry than is warranted for this conversation.
Re:GitHub for Mac
by bradleyland on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @03:44PM
(#2684804)
I didn't mean my reply to be a point by point rebuttal. Your description seemed to match GitX pretty well, so I figured I'd mention it.
The rest of my reply was pointing out how I perceived this to be different than GitX, which was tangential to the point, but I didn't really think a separate reply was required. Sorry for the confusion.
I'm mostly discussing GUI trends (as a Mac developer who cares about this stuff), using GitHub as an example (which, as you say, gets job done great, but I say that it can be improved).