News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“My Octopus Teacher” defied convention by freewilly1040 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:57PM (#26836345)
The thing I didn't much like about this movie was that the ending tried to put an activist spin on what the filmmaker was doing. One of the last shots is of him and a bunch of his friends going out on a dive (as opposed to just him), as if this will help the octopus somehow.

In fact, the relationship between him and the octopus only works because the filmmaker has a large patch of pristine coast seemingly to himself. If it was some common thing to go diving there the habitat would likely be destroyed. As such the film is not really about activism at all, it's about a man enjoying privileged access to a natural resource.

Re:“My Octopus Teacher” defied convention by ghawr on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:54PM (#26838382)
While I understand your sentiment, I think the primary objective of the filmmaker is to make a good film. Sometimes that means doing something to simply get an emotional response out of it. If it’s effective in giving people a deeper appreciation of the animal and that ecosystem, then I'd argue it was a good choice and not at all misguided as you're portraying it.
Re:“My Octopus Teacher” defied convention by sneak on Friday April 16, 2021 @04:53PM (#26838963)
Just because a film can make a large positive emotional response doesn't mean it was a good film, just as a film that can make a large negative emotional response is a bad film.

I think GP was criticizing the cheap, low-hanging feelgood duct taped onto the end. It doesn't make the film better.

Re:“My Octopus Teacher” defied convention by sneak on Saturday April 17, 2021 @01:09AM (#26841728)
edit: *is not a bad film
Re:“My Octopus Teacher” defied convention by HKH2 on Sunday April 18, 2021 @03:40AM (#26850584)
Any documentary with added music already has spin. I don't see how making it a bit more contrived will make much of a difference.