News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kelly Criterion by a11r on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:30PM (#26835952)
For anyone actively managing investment portfolios, a deep understanding of the Kelley criterion is very important. For example, it is common practice to use "Half Kelly" to size positions, but most sources only provide a hand-wavey intuitive explanation. Thorp's paper[2] quantifies the benefits for any fraction of the "full Kelly" bet and its implications. In addition to Poundstone's book [1] I strongly recommend Ed Thorp's highly readable paper[2].

[1] Poundstone, William (2005), Fortune's Formula: The Untold Story of the Scientific Betting System That Beat the Casinos and Wall Street, [2]https://wayback.archive-it.org/all/20090320125959/http://www...

Re:Kelly Criterion by hodder on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:39PM (#26836073)
Understanding Kelly criterion is almost useless in practical investment management. I’m a professional trader and former quant and I don’t know a single actual pro who uses anything like Kelly to size bets. I’m not saying understanding the methodology isn’t commonplace and useful, I’m saying this isn’t how portfolios are structured in the real world. Securities are not like a deck of cards.

This seems to be discussed at greater length among retail traders who have no way of even knowing their odds than any professional.

Re:Kelly Criterion by kqr on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:56PM (#26836335)
I don't have the source at hand but by looking at what data we have from successful investors, many of them have returns that statistically seem like what you'd expect from E log X strategies.

In fact, it's not even a point of debate. If you target growth, you are using the Kelly criterion whether you know it or not. It's just the name for the thing you do when you optimise for growth.

Re:Kelly Criterion by pushrax on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:40PM (#26837514)
There are kind of two main points by Kelly:

1. Investment returns are multiplicative and should be looked at as a geometric series. To optimize the portfolio, optimize for geometric mean not arithmetic mean.

2. To optimize the geometric mean of some specific games, apply some specific mathematical rules that Kelly derived.

Then 2nd part is not applicable to general market investing. The 1st part is.

Re:Kelly Criterion by kqr on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:42PM (#26837542)
I would be surprised and perhaps a little disappointed if any professional investors think of E log X optimisation as the latter.
Re:Kelly Criterion by pushrax on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:44PM (#26837564)
I think it’s more a difference in what people think the term “Kelly criterion” means, which is somewhat fair. The concept of optimizing for geometric mean came before Kelly, as well as the math showing that optimizing for log utility is a way to do that.
Re:Kelly Criterion by howlin on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:03PM (#26836429)
Kelly can work if you can properly model your uncertainty over the probability of outcomes and take this into account. You can either do some sort of Bayesian averaging over your posterior belief of the risk, or you can use the pessimistic side of the confidence interval of the actual risk probability.
Re:Kelly Criterion by andrewprock on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:28PM (#26836718)
The key understanding of the Kelly Criterion is that you need to scale your investment size with risk; riskier investments require smaller investments. How you estimate risk and how that informs your investments is rather fluid, but understanding it is the cornerstone of professional investing.

If you don't understand that, then you are going to go eventually go bust.

Re:Kelly Criterion by anotheranon631 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:47PM (#26836214)
Re:Kelly Criterion by robocat on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:07PM (#26837219)
From the second article[2] that follows: “This makes sense because the problem with the Kelly Formula for portfolio management is that it looks at each bet individually” i.e. the Kelly Criterion bets your whole portfolio on a single position. I presume any strategy that has multiple positions (a portfolio) cannot use the Kelly Criterion by definition.

[2] https://blog.alphatheory.com/2013/01/kelly-criterion-in-prac...

[0] https://alphatheory.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/3600356960... has an explanation of the “Alpha Theory” which I couldn’t quickly find on the alpha theory site.

Re:Kelly Criterion by mrfredward on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:15PM (#26837298)
Take a look at the "Many Assets" subheading in the original post.
Re:Kelly Criterion by robocat on Friday April 16, 2021 @04:14PM (#26838563)
From what I can tell “Kelly Criterion” originally applied to one bankroll and a single repeated bet.

It seems the choosing the optimal strategy for allocating a portfolio to maximise growth is often called “Kelly style”, “Kelly strategies”, “Kelly methods”, and also “Kelly criterion” by some people (which is why I was confused).

The details of an optimal strategy are completely different depending upon your assumptions (how reallocation is performed as new information is received, accounting for error in predicted outcomes, blah blah blah) so there cannot be a single definition for the Kelly Criterion for a portfolio, instead there are a variety of strategies (each with different assumptions and constraints).

For example the “many assets” model you refer to looks like it models a single market correlation (alpha), and not the multiple correlations within a real market.

Disclaimer: I am not an investment professional, but a small amount of software experience with hedge fund NAV calculations.

Re:Kelly Criterion by hogFeast on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:04PM (#26836452)
A tiny firm managing under $100m uses Kelly...and...

The post you replied to is right. The fundamental principle of Kelly is that you know your edge, in the markets that is mostly untrue. Funds will volatility-weight their portfolio but this isn't the same as Kelly in practice. Most fund managers will also weight their portfolio towards their "best" position but that is not necessarily based on return. Indeed, picking high return assets is only half the battle.

I also bet a lot, so I am familiar with Kelly. It is totally unusable in finance, no-one uses it in finance, and retail investors have an obsession with it.

In particular, if you Kelly-weight a value portfolio (which the firm linked to in your post is) then you are setting cash on fire. And if you Kelly-weight a long/short portfolio (again, the firm linked to appears to be doing this) then you are setting cash on fire. It is important to understand how a tool works at a practical level.

Re:Kelly Criterion by anotheranon631 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:30PM (#26836755)
“ The fundamental principle of Kelly is that you know your edge, in the markets that is mostly untrue.” Most every professional investor I’ve met attempts to quantify the risk-reward of each trade and size accordingly. I agree that naieve investors engage in false precision eg assuming backtest sharpe for position sizing, or ignoring correlated risks. That makes them size too aggressively. But that doesn’t mean pros don’t try their best to estimate risk reward and size accordingly. Indeed many of the best traders ever (Buffett, Soros) put on massive bets when the risk reward were highly in their favor.
Re:Kelly Criterion by hogFeast on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:05PM (#26837806)
Correct. That is the gap in understanding here.

When I place a bet, I can estimate my edge because the outcome is binary. When the outcome is continuous, it is far more tricky. It is like saying a kid who learns to ride his trike is ready for MotoGP...they are just totally different.

And yes Soros put on big bets, but what you are missing with Soros is the fact that his hit rate was still 30%. Most of the stuff he did didn't work out, macro is largely bets on skewness not returns. Buffett had a higher hit rate but trying to suggest someone optimise a strategy based on what literally the best investor of all time did is...not smart. Even if you were better than Buffett, you might not be lucky.

The reason why Kelly doesn't work with value investing in particular is because your returns are largely random, you know that your portfolio has an edge but you don't usually know which position is going to revalue.

The reason why Kelly doesn't work with long-short in particular is because you aren't only betting on return but correlation. Anyone who runs Kelly will eventually get a correlation spike and blow up (this is also roughly true of macro, again why Soros isn't a good example, he largely bet on skewness).

I was a "pro" so I am also aware of what most pros do. Again, investors don't only look at return, they have to look at correlation, volatility (note that if you are betting on sports, you don't have to worry about things like correlation).

Re:Kelly Criterion by anotheranon631 on Friday April 16, 2021 @03:22PM (#26838014)
It sounds like we might mostly agree in substance and a debate over semantics isn’t productive.

I agree that “the inputs to the Kelly formula are imprecise and therefore we should not mindlessly implement its recommendations.”

I agree that retail investors should not model their 401k allocations like Soros and Buffett.

Having run a factor neutral long short book I’m extremely familiar with the role of correlation and volatility in portfolio management and position sizing. As others have noted, there are extensions of Kelly (and related portfolio construction formulas) that account for correlations.

I disagree that risk-reward (broadly defined) shouldn’t be the primary bet sizing metric. I think many investors ignore risk reward calculations in their sizing and they would be better off if they paid attention to it. Many of the smartest investors I know have their entire sizing strategy based on risk reward.

To suggest that active investors should ignore risk reward / odds / whatever you want to call it, is wrong, in my opinion.

Re:Kelly Criterion by throwaway823882 on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:18PM (#26836612)
> It is important to understand how a tool works at a practical level.

There needs to be a term for "This page you're reading is bogus horseshit theory, do not try to apply it practically".

Re:Kelly Criterion by WanderPanda on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:32PM (#26836785)
“Academic”
Re:Kelly Criterion by fighterpilot on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:05PM (#26837187)
Second this. Nobody actually uses it. It's a bit too theoretical.
Re:Kelly Criterion by User23 on Friday April 16, 2021 @12:36PM (#26836039)
For any kind of trading activity, the most important skill to have is risk management. You can get everything else completely wrong, but if you have your risk management down you're still in the game and can learn from your mistakes. If you don't you're liable to be ruined and be out of the game until you can build back a bankroll some other way.
Re:Kelly Criterion by throwastrike on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:59PM (#26837733)
Ed Thorp AND Claude Shannon! One of the best nontechnical finance books ever written.

In practice though, positioning doesn’t work like that in modern times because a lot of your entries and exits happen around liquidity events. However, it is very pertinent for biotech stocks and special situations where you are dealing with discrete outcomes.