You should compare it to something that's near its performance class, since people are obviously not going to buy the Model S just to save money. That's going to be a future model.
At under 5 seconds 0-60, the Model S sport is supposedly going to have performance in the 500 horsepower BMW M5 range, which gets a combined MPG of 13 (11 city, 17 highway).
Besides that, the M5 is more like $90k.
If you are driving that much, you will wear out the batteries even faster than the norm causing the battery cost to be even higher.
Alternately, it's cheaper to drive a fuel-efficient gasoline car like a Volkswagon Jetta until gasoline gets up to $27/gallon.