News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pinboard.in service limited - FBI raided hosting company ... by _delirium on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @07:14PM (#2680806)
I believe the current status is: no definitive resolution of whether there should be any compensation required, but, paying compensation is not typically done currently, and no strong precedent requires it, while some precedent holds that it isn't required.

A 2008 post by a libertarian law professor (http://volokh.com/posts/1209706276.shtml) argued that the Takings Clause (which requires compensation if e.g. land is taken to build a highway or military base) should also require the government to pay compensation to innocent third parties inconvenienced or harmed during the course of a criminal investigation. But, that post noted that no high courts had actually held that, and at least one appeals court had just held to the contrary.

This is in the normal case, at least; things would probably be different if it were deemed to be some sort of overt act, e.g. if a police chief orders a raid designed to intentionally damage an innocent third party's interests (and you have evidence to show that).

There are no comments on this comment yet.