Re:You don't understand something until you think it's obvious.
by btilly on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @03:58PM
(#2680140)
I've thought before about Knuth's proposal (see http://micromath.wordpress.com/2008/04/14/donald-knuth-calcu... for his description) that Calculus be introduced using Big-O, little-o notation. I once drew up a curriculum based on it, and it seems to avoid the issue that you describe.
In particular the idea of approximation seems inherently useful. All approximations take the form something = approximation + error, so the idea of having a useful language for the error seems useful. Once you have that language, the tangent line is just a particularly useful example. Only after working with tangent lines for a while would you get to the definition of the derivative.
The nicest thing about the approach is that all of the derivative rules are easy to remember for tangent lines. Product rule? Multiply the tangent line approximations, throw away the high order term. The chain rule? Plug one function into the other. And so on.
The only thing that I found did not flow naturally was L'Hopital's Rule. However that rule is a source of confusion for students who don't understand the importance of the precondition that the limits be of the form 0/0 or infinity/infinity. And furthermore all standard cases where it is useful are obvious upon inspection for anyone who knows Big-O/little-o notation. (Don't believe me? Crack open a textbook and look at the problems that you're supposed to use the rule for. They are all obvious.)
In particular the idea of approximation seems inherently useful. All approximations take the form something = approximation + error, so the idea of having a useful language for the error seems useful. Once you have that language, the tangent line is just a particularly useful example. Only after working with tangent lines for a while would you get to the definition of the derivative.
The nicest thing about the approach is that all of the derivative rules are easy to remember for tangent lines. Product rule? Multiply the tangent line approximations, throw away the high order term. The chain rule? Plug one function into the other. And so on.
The only thing that I found did not flow naturally was L'Hopital's Rule. However that rule is a source of confusion for students who don't understand the importance of the precondition that the limits be of the form 0/0 or infinity/infinity. And furthermore all standard cases where it is useful are obvious upon inspection for anyone who knows Big-O/little-o notation. (Don't believe me? Crack open a textbook and look at the problems that you're supposed to use the rule for. They are all obvious.)