The stakes for software freedom have never been higher.
From the preamble:
Our General Public Licenses are designed to make sure that you have the freedom to distribute copies of free software (and charge for this service if you wish), that you receive source code or can get it if you want it, that you can change the software or use pieces of it in new free programs; and that you know you can do these things.
This jives well with Linus's intention of "I give you software to do whatever you want with, and if you make improvements you have to give them back"This jives well with Linus's intention of "I give you software to do whatever you want with, and if you make improvements you have to give them back"
Except the GPL does not require you give any improvements back. It only requires that you give the same freedoms to whoever you give the improved software to. That is, the end users. There are plenty of enterprise "appliances" that come with modified GPL code that is only given to the companies that pay for these computers. That is perfectly within the spirit of the gpl, because it's goal is to give the end users freedom.
edit:
What else would be the point of "that you can change the software" without having a means to run it?
Porting the software to new hardware?
It is the goal of Stallman and the Free Software Foundation. Free software licenses are one of the means to that end.
Free software started in universities decades ago. The software was written for Unix computers, many years before things like trusted computing. The GPLv2 reflects this environment: it takes hardware freedom for granted and focuses entirely on software freedom. Tivoization was an unforeseen development.
But it is. Let's quote another paragraph of the preamble too, shall we?
if you distribute copies of such a program, whether gratis or for a fee, you must give the recipients all the rights that you have.
This surely says, in spirit, that if you as manufacturer have the right to deploy this software on certain hardware, that the recipient must have the same rights?Linus's intention of "I give you software to do whatever you want with, and if you make improvements you have to give them back"
This, on the other hand, is not a stated goal of GPLv2. Your obligation, as a software distributor, is only downstream (your recipients/customers), not upstream (your suppliers).
I don’t think it is that much of a stretch to say preventing people from running modified versions of the software went against the goals of GPLv2 to allow users the ability to “change the software or use pieces of it in new free programs”
Not being able to run the software you change certainly means you can’t use it.
There was a printer driver that RMS wanted to change but couldn't. If the system he was working with had had code signing for printer drivers and refused to run with his modifications because of it, we'd have had the TiVo clause in the very first version of the GPL already.
Some of us were always suspicious before the change -- "what if RMS sells out and v(n+1) grants non-reciprocity to his employer" type of crap -- but we went with v2+ because it was popular at the time. I don't think I've seen "v3 or later", probably because we've been burned already.