News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by koenigdavidmj on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @12:43PM (#2679409)
What is with this guy's aversion to uppercase?
Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by zachbeane on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @02:20PM (#2679811)
The aversion is restricted to capitalizing the initial word of a sentence.

It's easier to rearrange words in a sentence and join or split sentences in a paragraph if the first word of a sentence is not capitalized.

Capitalizing the first word of a sentence can also lose information.

It's also helpful to identify people who focus on the trivial.

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by akavi on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @02:38PM (#2679866)
Except it isn't trivial; it materially damaged the ease with which I could read the essay.

As a long-time English reader, I've internalized the idea that there will be a capital letter at the beginning of a sentence. So when it's lacking, especially when the beginning of a sentence corresponds to a newline as in the beginnings of paragraphs in this essay, my immediate mental response is to assume that I've overshot the sentence's beginning, and immediately to backtrack to find it.

Overriding this behavior takes mental effort which detracts from the ease with which I can read. Making it harder for your readers to consume your ideas is hardly a trivial issue.

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by tincholio on Thursday June 23, 2011 @07:46AM (#2687499)
For Emacs users:

(defun capitalize-naggum () "Capitalizes text written in Erik Naggum's annoying no-caps style" (interactive) (save-excursion (goto-char (point-min)) (aux-naggum (point))))

(defun aux-naggum (current-point) "Recursively capitalize the buffer, moving sentence to sentence. Valid punctuation symbols are [.?!]" (re-search-forward "[a-z]" nil 0 nil) (if (= current-point (point)) t (capitalize-word -1) (re-search-forward "[.!?]") (aux-naggum (point))))

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by jeramey on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @08:06PM (#2680959)
e. e. cummings might have a thing or two to say about a thing or two regarding the use of capitalization. It can be worthwhile to overlook or adapt to someone's stylistic peccadilloes if the ideas they have are interesting and useful.

Not that I'm casting judgment in regards to that in what either Naggum or cummings wrote! ;-)

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by gorm on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:30PM (#2680508)
It wouldn't take that many lines of elisp to capitalize first word in sentence before gnus burped it out over NNTP.
Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by sofal on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @06:24PM (#2680672)
Capitalizing the first word of a sentence can also lose information.

I've never heard this, but are you talking about proper nouns that override regular words?

It's also helpful to identify people who focus on the trivial.

Would you say the same thing about txt spk, or does that cross the line for you?

edit: s/pronouns/proper nouns/

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by loup-vaillant on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @06:20PM (#2680668)
> Capitalizing the first word of a sentence can also lose information.

Only if you are using a lousy keyboard layout for your language. I'm a native French speaker, and my layout (Bépo) let me type ÉÈÊÀÆŒ without having to remember any weird combination.

I can't think of significant loss of information besides diacritics.

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by zachbeane on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @06:26PM (#2680679)
In English, it can make a big difference in meaning if something is a proper noun or not.
Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by jzawodn on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @01:19PM (#2679574)
Yeah, I guess he wasn't concerned about putting any effort into making it easy for others to read his thoughts.

sigh

Written text is supposed to be written to be parsed by humans. Why do people forget that?

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by bdhe on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @02:03PM (#2679739)
He's also inconsistent. He capitalizes 'I' and Emacs and Lisp (among other things).

I remember a study that said people read based on shapes of words, particularly ascenders, descenders and edges (i.e., first and last letters). Does capitalizing the first letter of the sentence make a difference? If it does, do people that read languages like German which has more capitalization (but the same script) adapt to it?

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by kjetil on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @11:44AM (#2683632)
> He's also inconsistent. He capitalizes 'I' and Emacs and Lisp (among other things).

No, you're missing the point.

Naggum didn't eschew all capital letters, only where they led to loss of information (ie. failure to separate common and proper nouns).

Emacs and Lisp are proper nouns and therefore capitalized. Common nouns that happen to start a sentence are not.

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by Derbasti on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @03:32PM (#2680063)
How does a German adapt? Poorly. I nearly stopped reading because of that.

It freakes out my wetware text parser to have two spaces before punctuation and no capitalization at the beginning of sentences. At least he did not put punctuation inside quotes...

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by xyzzyz on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @03:33AM (#2682135)
It's funny, because his capitalization and punctuation are his conscious decisions he wrote about quite a few times. He said it is easy to programmatically upcase first words of the sentences, but it is no easy to do it the other way, without losing meaning. Sentences without first word capitalized are also easier to manipulate.

I personally have no problem with reading text written in a such way.

Re:Erik Naggum on Emacs and muscle memory by cageface on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @03:54PM (#2680133)
Naggum was one of the net's all-time greatest cranks. He almost singlehandedly turned comp.lang.lisp into a minefield.