Re:Modelling a Wealth Tax Correctly (2020)
by readthenotes1 on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @12:21PM
(#26794675)
"Up until this point in history, the stock market has never been negative over the course of a ten-year timespan"
that's true if you ignore inflation.
In real dollar terms, accounting for inflation, you have to wait nearly 20 years--but only 4 times in the last 140 years.
The New York Times article I posted calculates the math differently. For instance, the Great Depression was a deflationary period, not inflationary.
In any case, my point still stands. Whether we're talking 10, 15 or 20 years, the wealthy hold on to their wealth. And if we ever enter a long-term recession, wealth taxes could be reversed as easily as they were enacted. But why would we? The Great Depression hit the poor much harder than it did the Rockefellers.
If we are ever in a period when the stock market has been flat or negative for ten years or more, I'm sure such a wealth tax can be rescinded.
But if we are ever in such a period, the bottom four-fifths of Americans are going to be in much, much more catastrophic shape, and the small tear we shed for the super-rich that the government is still nibbling away at a fraction of their treasure during that time (presumably to spend on the massive bread lines that would exist) will be fairly irrelevant.
1. https://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/26/your-money/stocks-and-bon...