News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Scala really Faster than Java? by scott_s on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @10:48AM (#2678942)
Frankly, their discussion is a bit confusing because they did have optimized versions discussed in the text. And the optimized Scala version did make fundamental changes to the algorithm. They could have kept a better division between the two - idiomatic versus optimized - in both their results and their discussion.

So, jbooth is not accusing them of intellectual dishonesty. And if I consider the following three suppositions: jbooth's understanding of the paper was not complete, your understanding of the paper was not complete, and the people who wrote the paper are smart and hard working; then I simply conclude that performing and writing about this kind of study in a clear manner that will confuse none is very, very hard.

Re:Is Scala really Faster than Java? by loup-vaillant on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @11:00AM (#2678994)
> your understanding of the paper was not complete,

Indeed: I have not read it. But now I plan to.

(Edit: since when a pubic recognition of one's own fault is worth a down vote? My not having read the paper provides meaningful context, by temporarily undermining my authority. Down vote the grand parent, but leave this one at 1 point!)

Re:Is Scala really Faster than Java? by scott_s on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @11:42AM (#2679213)
I agree with your edit, and I tried to correct for it.