Re:Supplements are a $30B racket–what experts recommend (2018)
by 1996 on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:59PM
(#26783583)
N Acetyl Cysteine is a supplement that work wonders for respiratory infections, and against acetaminophen poisoning
Magnesium Glycinate is a supplement that works wonders for falling asleep - and likewise for melatonin
And that's just top of my head. I'm quite certain some doctors would like to ban supplements, but I think it may be due more to their desires to remove competition from the market
Re:Supplements are a $30B racket–what experts recommend (2018)
by TimTheTinker on Monday April 12, 2021 @03:17PM
(#26783813)
L-Tyrosine worked wonders for my "inattentive ADHD"-like symptoms, and it works better and has fewer side-effects than the medication my physician prescribed.
Just a non-essential amino acid that is a precursor for dopamine (and epinephrine/norepinephrine by extension), 2 thyroid hormones, and interestingly enough, melanin.
Not medical advice. My point is that it turned out what I needed was a "supplement".
Re:Supplements are a $30B racket–what experts recommend (2018)
by 1996 on Monday April 12, 2021 @03:25PM
(#26783942)
Very interesting, I'll give it a try!
Having more options is better than having less, so I don't see supplements ever going away - if anything, I believe they will grow in places where they are not as big yet (say, EU) and where there is no competition (so not in Asia due to TCM)
Re:Supplements are a $30B racket–what experts recommend (2018)
by dfsegoat on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:54PM
(#26783525)
Note that the definition of "supplement" varies a bit internationally vs. the US in terms of regulatory landscape and safety [1].
For instance Canada is quite rigorous in their definition and licensing application process for supplements - which they call "Natural Health Products" [2]. The EU is rigorous as well, from my limited understanding.
The US is a bit more like the wild west: You pretty much just can't make false claims, or adulterate your product with unsafe compounds - however enforcement on the last point is almost always a reactive process [e.g. 3].
Re:Supplements are a $30B racket–what experts recommend (2018)
by avgDev on Monday April 12, 2021 @05:14PM
(#26785294)
What an awful article.
I could post case studies and research, but I don't have time to look so trust me please.
In healthy people meaning people who are feeling like they are firing on all cylinders, supplements may be useless. However, as we grow older, take medication and get certain health condition supplements can be extremely beneficial.
There are supplement stacks for people who have mitochondrial dysfunction. I can't recall the exact number but it is few essential nutrients.
I have read case studies of individuals having neurological symptoms and pain going into complete remission after 6 months of using supplements. In one case, stopping the supplements resulted in symptoms reemerging.
One should avoid 'bro' science and try to find actual case studies or medical research but supplements do help with many different health problems.
Re:Supplements are a $30B racket–what experts recommend (2018)
by gamblor956 on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:36PM
(#26783273)
Ironically, the article then proceeds to note that a variety of supplements are actually useful to many people, depending on their needs, and indeed, notes that only multivitamins are actually a waste of money.
Magnesium Glycinate is a supplement that works wonders for falling asleep - and likewise for melatonin
And that's just top of my head. I'm quite certain some doctors would like to ban supplements, but I think it may be due more to their desires to remove competition from the market
Just a non-essential amino acid that is a precursor for dopamine (and epinephrine/norepinephrine by extension), 2 thyroid hormones, and interestingly enough, melanin.
Not medical advice. My point is that it turned out what I needed was a "supplement".
Having more options is better than having less, so I don't see supplements ever going away - if anything, I believe they will grow in places where they are not as big yet (say, EU) and where there is no competition (so not in Asia due to TCM)
Magnesium is required for serotonin production. And modern farming practices virtually eliminate it from our diet.
For instance Canada is quite rigorous in their definition and licensing application process for supplements - which they call "Natural Health Products" [2]. The EU is rigorous as well, from my limited understanding.
The US is a bit more like the wild west: You pretty much just can't make false claims, or adulterate your product with unsafe compounds - however enforcement on the last point is almost always a reactive process [e.g. 3].
1- https://www.fda.gov/food/dietary-supplements
2- https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/drugs-health...
3- https://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls-market-withdrawals-safety...
I could post case studies and research, but I don't have time to look so trust me please.
In healthy people meaning people who are feeling like they are firing on all cylinders, supplements may be useless. However, as we grow older, take medication and get certain health condition supplements can be extremely beneficial.
There are supplement stacks for people who have mitochondrial dysfunction. I can't recall the exact number but it is few essential nutrients.
I have read case studies of individuals having neurological symptoms and pain going into complete remission after 6 months of using supplements. In one case, stopping the supplements resulted in symptoms reemerging.
One should avoid 'bro' science and try to find actual case studies or medical research but supplements do help with many different health problems.