Re:I'm the guy who bought 259684 Bitcoins for under $3000 ye...
by pnathan on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @01:18PM
(#2679565)
If you want to view BTC as a commodity, it does look very boiler-room-y.
If you want to view BTC as a currency, it doesn't look that way... IMO.
Re:I'm the guy who bought 259684 Bitcoins for under $3000 ye...
by joe_the_user on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @02:15PM
(#2679788)
Uh,
BTC appears entirely dysfunctional as currency.
"currency refers to a generally accepted medium of exchange." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency
BTC is neither generally accepted nor does it have the STABLE VALUE needed to become more accepted as a medium of exchange. And last element is something the Bitcommunists just utterly miss. Because a currency is medium, just a means, it will not function unless its value is stable. Not decreasing OR increasing.
Whenever the BTC shills tout the increasing value, they've accomplished the old "switch-a-roo" from currency to speculative commodity.
Re:I'm the guy who bought 259684 Bitcoins for under $3000 ye...
by pnathan on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:13PM
(#2680449)
Well, as a currency, for it to 'increase in value', it needs to be more broadly accepted. That would increase ability for people to use it.
But currencies are also dual-purposed as commodities (c.f., forex traders).
The Bitcoin "community" is an emergent, distributed boiler room. They could just as easily be selling pink clam shells, tulips, or shares in an insolvent company that had a business plan to make pool cleaning agents. The underlying commodity doesn't matter. What does matter is that the widely disbursing the underlying commodity early gave them enough of a following, including folks who are savvy enough to think that they are the ones getting rich off the marks (a classic element of fraud), to attempt to convince other people that there is actually intrinsic value in what they are selling.
Every article about Bitcoin which makes it to HN -- yes, including ones in mainstream publications -- is in effect a PR hit planted by a new breed of the old boiler room scam.