Suggestion to PG: infinite scrolling instead of "Unknown or expired link."
HN would be well suited to an "infinite scrolling" UI, similar to dzone.com
Constantly getting the "expired link" message after pressing "more" is getting a little tedious. It feels like the HN architecture is broken around this.
I assume HN works this way because HN creates static pages which eventually get replaced with a new set of static pages as more items are submitted? Infinite scrolling would fix that because pages would not need to contain a consistent number of rows.
(
9 comments
| 17 points
| on HN
)
However, I agree that it's annoying to have to reload the page before being able to click on the rapidly-expiring "More" link. I often click on a good number of stories on the front page, and by the time I've read them and get to the "More" link, it will have expired. Then when I reload the page, I'll have to rescan it since some new links will have shown up in the meantime. Then when I click on the "More" link... expired again!
How about a bit of caching? Maybe taking a snapshot of the top 5 pages or so every hour? It wouldn't be up-to-the-minute, but one would be able to scroll through a list of links with a consistent relative order (rather than reencountering the same links as they move up and down.) Maybe the cached version could be offered as a separate section of the site, up there with "new", "threads", "comments", etc.
Serving links that break in such a short time is a bug. I'm sure there's plenty of simple ways to make that link work as expected. I haven't looked at the Arc code, but I have implemented pagination dozens of time. Never with links that expire though.
The continuation style seems to imply that "next page" means "the next page of results from the time you requested the initial page". Which doesn't really have to hold true. It'd be better to just give the users more links. (As I said previously in a feature request)
Not that I believe infinite scroll is the right solution though.
[edit: This reply doesn't really convey the rage I feel when I get one of those expired links. I'd tear limbs off a developer for that...]
It's not a bug, but a feature of Arc and other continuation servers. If continuations aren't reclaimed by the server (and those links invalidated), the server runs out of RAM.
I discovered it a few months ago and can't imagine living without it anymore.
but I really don't care for infinite scrolling on desktops.