• There are reactors in operation that were designed in the age of slide rules. Even in 1980, $5 million "supercomputers" ($15M in today's dollars) were less powerful than my phone.
• In "An Overview of Radiation Embrittlement Modeling for Reactor Vessel Steels" 1993, http://books.google.com/books?id=quzCvTWt9CMC&pg=PA99... the oldest work in the bibliography specifically on embrittlement that I see is from the 1970s with the bulk being in the 1980s.
• When faced with uncertainty, engineers set the limits high enough to encompass the worst case.
• When faced with approximation, engineers set the limits to encompass the error of the calculation.
A poorly understood phenomenon coupled with primitive, coarse grained models (in order to be computable by the existing resources) is going to get you an overly conservative operating range.
25 years of studying what actually happens in live reactors, 25 years of theoretical studying, and unimaginably fast computers for verifying models and simulating situations is going to get you a different answer to the question.
More likely is that bringing old plants up to standard was too expensive. Or even worse, taking them off the grid.
In my view this is the real danger of nuclear power: New plants are probably quite safe but they are very expensive to maintain when they get old. On the other hand, if you relax the standard they are more profitable the older they get. So at some point you end up with a lot of old plants that are extremely expensive to maintain or shut down.
We've had quite a few very narrow escapes in the US. Here's just one:
Davis-Besse http://events.nace.org/library/corrosion/NuclearIndustry/nuc... >High pressure inside the reactor vessel pushed the stainless steel outward into the cavity formed by the boric acid. The stainless steel bent but did not break. Cooling water remained inside the reactor vessel not because of thick carbon steel but due to a thin layer of stainless steel.
Picture of corrosion here: http://www.nirs.org/photogallery/davisbesseimages.htm
Personally, I'll support nuclear power if based on a reasonably clean low-waste producing technology, and if it can be proven that a safe passive shut-down is possible under station black-out conditions, without human intervention.
Comparing with this other article, it seems are taking figures in °Fahrenheit and dividing them.
http://hosted2.ap.org/COGRA/54828a5e8d9d48b7ba8b94ba38a9ef22...
I.e. 300 °F / 200 °F = 150%, and 356 °F / 200 °F = 178%.
People tend to rate dangers they don't understand very well much higher than those they do.
http://inmotion.magnumphotos.com/essay/chernobyl
If you can point me at a similar legacy of birth defects suffering and eviction from the land, tied to the BP spill, please do so.
I'm not belittling the terrible effects on the Gulf of Mexico, but for people on land, I'm not sure I'd quite put it in the Chernobyl league.
The 'league' of a disaster in your head is not an important metric; the oil spill is responsible for far more environmental contamination, food supply reduction, and long term ecological damage than Chernobyl.
Coal plants kill more people every year without even being called 'disasters' - the birth defects caused by the radiation being put in the atmosphere by those plants is distributed over a far larger area, but it's way out of the 'Chernobyl league'.
You are attributing extra importance to Chernobyl because it causes an unusual type of localized damage, but it never caused that much of it.
This is a tragedy, of course, but nowhere near the level of a nuclear disaster like we're seeing in Japan right now.
This is a tragedy, of course, but nowhere near the level of a nuclear disaster like we're seeing in Japan right now.
Last I heard the current death toll from Fukushima was 2, and those workers were killed by the tsunami itself.
Amazing. I know that there are many who still think nuclear energy is safe, but I think it's inherently unsafe, not because the original designs are flawed or anything technical like that, but because people seem to get greedy or too complacent around them, and that's what can ultimately lead to nuclear disasters.