Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by rusk on Saturday April 10, 2021 @05:44AM
(#26760255)
I think under market conditions you would be continuously tweaking the model, and manufacturing processes, based on feedback eg wrt robustness, comfort etc and also taking into account changing usage parameters/expectations, changes in material supply costs, regulatory requirements etc
Of course these concerns matter more if you’re making a lot of these “widgets” but even in the case of a one off you’re going to have servicing costs and the occasional redesign/replacement/upgrade ...
It’s not that far out of line with software - widely used products go through tight highly iterative development cycles whereas one off solutions tend to be just “good enough” with bug fixing and the occasional feature request.
Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by macando on Saturday April 10, 2021 @05:36AM
(#26760220)
When you start drawing diagrams of non-trivial software, for instance Blender (an open source tool for building 3D models and animations), you start to understand how complex and complicated software is.
No other machine built by humans is that complex.
Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by spongeb00b on Saturday April 10, 2021 @06:03AM
(#26760337)
Regarding comments about manufacturing plants and the LCH, sure both of these examples aren’t software directly (but they also wouldn’t be possible without software), but they are also always under constant fixes, feature upgrades and optimisations.
Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by Ebisu77 on Saturday April 10, 2021 @05:55AM
(#26760301)
Ah yes, the famous Large Hadron Collider, the most complex piece of human engineering that doesn't have any software.
Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by cosmodisk on Saturday April 10, 2021 @09:24AM
(#26761309)
I think most of it is just software
Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by qznc on Saturday April 10, 2021 @05:55AM
(#26760303)
I'd say manufacturing plants are easily as complex as Blender.
Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by macando on Saturday April 10, 2021 @06:12AM
(#26760370)
How about car software?
I used Blender as an example because it's open source.
Re:Everyone is still terrible at creating software at scale
by qznc on Saturday April 10, 2021 @11:52AM
(#26762368)
I'm working on driver assistance stuff. In terms of raw functionality the software is not that complex. The complexity comes from other aspects: Safety-critical, hardware-software-codesign, commercial, resource constrained. Then, of course, organizational disfunction creates accidental complexity as it does everywhere. All of that together, and a software developer barely achieves a thousand lines of code per year.
Whereas if I design something in CAD, I send it to the printer, try it, improve it once, print again and never ever again think of it as long as it does it's job.