News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by Sanzig on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:25AM (#26750257)
Indeed, MNP makes this proclamation about once per quarter. I don't doubt that Canadian consumer debt is at an all-time high, and I agree that's concerning.

However, MNP's survey methodology makes the 52% number misleading: they basically ask a sample of the population if a $200 increase in monthly spending would make them unable to pay bills and meet debt obligations, and people self-report if that is the case or not. Most people don't have firm monthly budgets, so this is probably more a psychological excercise than a personal finance one.

Realistically, most people have more "give" in their monthly spending than they realize: if they get stuck with a $200 per month increase from somewhere, they can probably compensate by reducing bills (eg: cutting cable, changing phone/internet providers, shopping at the discount grocery store) and adjusting spending habits.

A better, more informative metric would be to sit down with a representative sample of the population and analyze their monthly bills to find the gap between inflexible expenditures (eg: rent/mortage, debt service, utilities, basic internet + phone packages, reasonable food expenditures) and monthly income. Knowing what the statistics are for that number is a better proxy for how close Canadians are to insolvency than self-reporting. But that's an awful lot of work.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by lumost on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:53AM (#26750594)
The latter methodology tends to produce laughably out of touch analysis. Mcdonalds and walmart both produced similar reports in order to demonstrate that you could in fact live on minimum wage in high cost areas without government subsidies.

Most healthy adults do not eat a diet of ramen as their mainstay. However an independent budget analysis would surely find that a healthy individual could downgrade their food purchases to just ramen (or another minimal cost set of foods) and find more give in the budget. As I recall the McDonalds budget also assumed the individual would not need phone or internet as they can use the library.

This quickly becomes an exercise in lifestyle dictation.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by Sanzig on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:24AM (#26750955)
Well, yes, but you have to draw the line somewhere. A long-term diet of ramen is not healthy, but drawing up a reference basket of middle-of-the-road nutritious food and pricing it based on median market prices for statistical purposes isn't unreasonable.

And we can agree that assuming that somebody uses the library for the internet is unreasonable - a better baseline is a basic package for both at local market rates.

The goal is to assess reasonable flexibility in cashflow. If the study author is biased towards trying to prove a predetermined outcome (eg: that minimum wage in high CoL areas is livable), the results are poisoned from the get-go: good luck getting repeat business from McDonalds' if your study unearths some unpleasant truths. It's the classic case of a metric becoming a goal and ceasing to be useful as a metric.

I do think this is certainly something a national statistical agency could do in a minimally biased fashion, if done rigorously.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by AstralStorm on Friday April 09, 2021 @03:05PM (#26754695)
Then again, not having resources or entertainment while having a soul-crushing boring job is a massive mental health risk.

Ignoring that is of course a nasty bias. Much like ignoring that you do sometimes have to buy clothing or shoes, you probably do have to spend on something to unwind. (What it is depends on the person.)

Likewise, ignoring cost of transportation is a chief sin of those analyses, even bus tickets are not free, and bicycles are not exactly fast.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by lumost on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:21PM (#26758395)
The problem with average and basket goods for this problem is that it's difficult to assess whether someone is financially constrained when their circumstances push them beyond the average.

As a minimal example, calorie and nutrition demands can vary by about 2x with height and biological factors and easily up to 3-4x if you consider more active lifestyles. You would generally expect some portion of the population in the study to need double or even quadruple the grocery cost per household member than the average. Are they cost burdened if most of their budget goes to grocery?

Similarly housing is heavily biased by when you purchased property comparing someone renting market rate housing to someone who lives in rent control or has owned property for a while is challenging. You can't exclude owners as they are the most likely to bankrupt in this scenario if they become cost burdened.

Even worse, for both of the above baselines the cost of goods can easily vary by 4x depending on where you live within a 50 mile radius when it comes to dense population centers. Starbucks employees in SF proper aren't going to commute 4+ hours through bay traffic to live in lower cost regions of California. They will inherently need to purchase grocery, housing, and other goods at higher than average prices.

These edge cases matter in this analysis as the outliers are the ones who probably will go bankrupt or otherwise exit the economy if the economic environment turns profoundly negative. If by circumstance the average household is happy, but 10% of households are on the brink - it wouldn't take much for things to take a serious turn.

All that being said, there is no reason a government agency couldn't devise a methodology based on the 90th or 99th percentile to capture these edge cases and report on a number that would more reasonably reflect the long-term outlook of houses under financial stress.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by jfengel on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:46AM (#26751199)
You're referring, I think, to this:

https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/mcdonalds-sample-budget-shee...

Highlights include:

* At minimum wage, it would require working 284 hours per month, or about 70 hours a week. To work merely 40 hours per week, they'd need to be earning $12.75.

* It assumes they can get health insurance for $20 a month, even though they're working two part-time jobs.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by scrivna on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:46AM (#26750501)
If you need to cut cable because you can’t afford some expenses is that not the definition of “unable to pay bills” the article mentions?
Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by prennert on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:05AM (#26750742)
If you can cut your bills so you can pay them, you don't become insolvent, because you maintain a positive cash flow.

In contrast, if you cannot cut your costs anymore and your outgoings exceed your income, you will have a negative cash flow. You are still not insolvent, but you will eat into your savings and credit lines and eventually become insolvent if you cannot recover.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by dahfizz on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:03AM (#26750728)
The question is whether the insolvency claim is valid. If an additional expense would require reshuffling your budget, but afterwards you can pay all your debt obligations, you are not insolvent.
Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by leetcrew on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:01AM (#26750699)
I would also be "unable to pay bills" if I struggled to heat my 10,000 sq ft mansion in the winter, but there's no particular reason anyone should care.
Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by mschuster91 on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:59AM (#26750673)
> Realistically, most people have more "give" in their monthly spending than they realize: if they get stuck with a $200 per month increase from somewhere, they can probably compensate by reducing bills (eg: cutting cable, changing phone/internet providers, shopping at the discount grocery store) and adjusting spending habits.

Not specific to Canada but rather generic: it's virtually without alternative in most parts of the world to pay enormous percentages of a net income for fixed, unchangeable stuff:

- rent

- car-related payments (even a beater requires gas, insurance and maintenance) or public transport

- some form of internet access

- food

Most people (~70% in the US!) don't have the savings to weather an unexpected 1000$ bill so it's fair to assume they've already stretched their budgets thin. It is very, very hard to cut in the variable part of monthly costs then, and impossible to cut on the fixed costs. And the coronavirus crisis with its various impacts, especially destroying a lot of "side hustles" like restaurant or other service "moonlight" jobs or sex work, hasn't made things better.

In fact, most of the Western societies' masses are barely kept afloat. It is a ticking bomb waiting to explode, we're seeing violent outbursts for over two years now - Yellow Vests in France, the BLM protests and the January putsch attempt in the US, covid-deniers nearly storming the Parliament in Germany, escalating covid-denier and youth riots in the Netherlands, religious-nationalist riots in Northern Ireland... societies are under immense tension, with demagogues fanning the flames.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by ac29 on Sunday April 11, 2021 @03:25AM (#26768250)
> Most people (~70% in the US!) don't have the savings to weather an unexpected 1000$ bill

According to this report the 60-80th percentile family has an income of $97k/year and a net worth of $423k: https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/files/scf20.pdf

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by tomrod on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:44AM (#26750471)
If psychological, this reveals the level of anxiety in the economy, which highlights a similar problem and suggests similar policy remediations.

Financial literacy really should be required in primary education.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by HarryHirsch on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:56AM (#26750638)
Housing prices and tuition have risen far faster than salaries in the last 20 years, meanwhile entry level jobs with possibility of advancement have dried up. Offering "financial literacy" as a solution in the current environment is like the "identity theft" scam, when people get the blame when a fraudster opened credit cards in their name. The system is not working any longer.
Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by throw0101a on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:11AM (#26750791)
> Housing prices

And interest rates have fallen, so monthly payments may be net the same. Rising prices could have an impact of down payments though.

In the US, inflation-adjusted mortgage payments seem to be at the lowest they've every been:

* https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2021/03/what-if-housing-pri...

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by HarryHirsch on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:34AM (#26751079)
I'd offer rental prices in Boston for consideration: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUURA103SEHA

The ladder was pulled up in the mid-nineties, and since 2008 it's out of reach.

Re:53% of Canadians on the Brink of Insolvency by tomrod on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:47AM (#26751216)
Instead of railing against policy that would help operating in a system because it's doesn't apply global changes, perhaps consider that the policy suggested still has demonstrable merit.