Re:AMD and Xilinx Stockholders Overwhelmingly Approve AMD’s ...
by rcxdude on Thursday April 08, 2021 @04:41PM
(#26743507)
> The paradigm is the least important, when it works, I don't know anyone in real world projects that didn't have to configure something manually through a tcl script because it was either not exposed in GUI or not working in GUI.
Worse is the other way around, a GUI control not exposed through the TCL scripts, which makes it very difficult to maintain a TCL build script which can be version controlled (unlike the project files: this particular IDE likes to completely rewrite its project files in a way which is not at all amenable to diffing).
The paradigm is the least important, when it works, I don't know anyone in real world projects that didn't have to configure something manually through a tcl script because it was either not exposed in GUI or not working in GUI.
My issue is not with 'visual programming' my issue is with the 'half-baked' part of the tools.
There are too many multi year old bugs that go acknowledged by Xilinx. The VHDL2008 standard came out more than a decade ago and from memory it was only in 2019 that they supported it as a valid simulation file in Vivado. There a plethora of autogenerate/copied/cached files that add a ridiculous amount of friction to any attempt of sane version control. There is just too much complexity in what I assume is an attempt to hide the shoe-horned messiness of the tcl backend and 'prettifying' the GUI frontend.