News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is the Technological Singularity? by Retric on Sunday June 19, 2011 @08:28PM (#2672397)
Slightly more intelligent than human is not the same as magic. Self improving AI is a nice theory but it assumes you can get better at everything at the same time without tradeoffs and that takes better hardware not just software. Science fiction is full of magic masquerading as technology, but it ignores the possibility that reality may not support that capability. Predicting the future requires more than simply extrapolating trends it also requires understanding physical limitations, early engines saw rapid increases in both HP and efficiency but that trend slowed down for a reason.

EX: Literal eternal life requires a universe that is capable of lasting that long. If the fundamental laws of physics limit either the age of the universe or the amount of useful work that can be done then you at some point everything dies. So no we are down from eternal to just really long life.

Also, 1.0001x a smart as a human is not really significant. 1,000 AI's 1.0001x smarter than a human is not going to be able to say beat 1 grand master at go without training or hundreds of years of preparation. I have no problem saying AI get's to quickly build better software, but building hardware at scale takes time.

There are no comments on this comment yet.