News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by abtinf on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:51AM (#26708819)
“Findings of these studies suggest that the risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection via the fomite transmission route is low, and generally less than 1 in 10,000, which means that each contact with a contaminated surface has less than a 1 in 10,000 chance of causing an infection.”
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by cortic on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @04:24AM (#26709426)
120 items on my average delivery, assuming a driver or stacker is infected that could mean every item is contaminated. I touch them 1-2 times to put them away, 3-4 times as i open and use the items.. So that could be 720 'touches', and that may be cheating as i am counting my many fingers as 1 and i don't live alone. So each contaminated delivery could risk infection as much as 1 in 14 (10,000/720). Through this pandemic i have had 21 deliveries. The twenty minutes it takes to wash them seems a very reasonable precaution.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by pbourke on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @04:45AM (#26709562)
Do you also sanitize your door knob, handle, pantry door handle, fridge/freezer handle, faucet controls, etc? Merely washing your hands when you’re done stowing items seems to be a better strategy.

Also it doesn’t stand to reason that you treat each item in your grocery delivery as having disjoint probability of harboring infectious virus. That’s clearly not true in the real world.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by cortic on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @05:05AM (#26709692)
I sanitize the items in the garage, as i fill a sanitized crate, then my hands, then lift them into the house. Its quick and easy, it also allows me to reduce contact with the driver.

To be honest i massively underestimated how often i touch some of these items in the first few days, coffee jars alone get touched 40+ times, jam and butter 12+, bread 18+, diluting squash 14+. even if i wash my hands after stowing away and subtract that number I'd probably be left with an average number of touches well over 6 after stowing.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by valarauko on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @05:03PM (#26717364)
I assume these numbers are for the lifetime of the product. Perhaps a more reasonable assumption would be to only consider touches within the first 3 days, since the surface contamination is essentially non-viable past that point.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by cortic on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @08:20PM (#26719036)
Those number are for the first 3 days. As i said i do not live alone.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by valarauko on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @11:49AM (#26726643)
In that case you'd really want to consider exposure for each person, rather than as a collective household.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by bgarbiak on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @04:48AM (#26709582)
I’m not sure you can count the probability this way. Each touch is a separate event, and for each touch you have 1 in 10000 chance of infection. So, it’s 1 * 720 / 10000 * 720.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by cortic on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @05:14AM (#26709757)
Maybe its not that accurate to count it that way, but 1 in 10,000 would mean to the layman that every 10,000 times you do this you should expect 1 case of C19, and i do this at least 720 times at every delivery. With more than 20 deliveries through the pandemic last year i have potentially touched 14,400 contaminated items which would practically guarantee a case of C19. Now i know not all of these would be contaminated, but i don't know which or how much. And since delivery drivers in my area rarely wear masks even at the house, i don't have a high amount of confidence in any delivered items.

-To be honest i massively underestimated how often i touch some of these items in the first few days, coffee jars alone get touched 40+ times, jam and butter 12+, bread 18+, diluting squash 14+.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by 0x72 on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @05:37AM (#26709900)
It's around 23.69% if my math is correct.

I mean, it's not nothing, but I wouldn't say "practically guarantee".

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by cortic on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @05:41AM (#26709923)
A 23% chance of a 1 in 10,000 chance thing happening every 14,400 chances? That can't be right.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by 0x72 on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @06:15AM (#26710123)
huh, 76%... my bad, forget I said anything.

p(a') = 1 - 1/10000

1 - p(a')^14400 = 0.76308930063962

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by bgarbiak on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @07:06AM (#26710438)
If you touch a parcel a second time then the first time doesn't count to anything. It's 1/10k again. It's like with a lottery: you can buy a coupon every day for years and win nothing, because every draw resets your chances.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by cortic on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @07:17AM (#26710497)
48 million to one lottery odds, running everyday I'd expect to win once in the next 131,506 years (48m/356). -this is why you don't win for 'years'. I'd also expect one winner for every 48 million players in a day.

Now a 1/10k taken twice is 2/10k, so taken 14 thousand times it is 14k/10k. Okay so this isn't technically how you add statistics, but its close enough to see the utility in washing items.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by bgarbiak on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:18AM (#26748363)
The are lotteries with bigger chances, but in all of them some numbers will be repeated over the years, and yours may never occur. You would have to use all possible combination for one draw to be sure. That's why it's not unusual to have draws without winner, sometimes a few in a row.

It's a flawed analogy, I admit, but with the parcel you would have to palpate its entire surface and lick the finger after every touch to infect yourself. Just touching it for the second time doesn't double the chance of infection. You may touch the same uncontaminated part you'd touched already (crossing the same numbers twice), the number of virus particles you've moved might not be enough to infect you, that you might have washed your hands in between the touches, and so on... Obviously, the more you "interact" with an item the chances grow, but certainly not as fast as you suggest. Add a time limit to all of that, and the fact that for every next item it's all back to 1/10k (second draw) - practically there's no way this number will ever grow over 1/1.

Excuse the non-fact-checked argument as I can't find a link now but I recently read that couriers and mailmen actually get ill less often than factory workers (and most of them caught the virus via airborne transmission). I don't mind if you wash everything you bring home from outside, but I don't see point in that, and certainly I wouldn't recommend that to anyone. It's wiser to focus on preventing airborne transmission than to waste time and efforts on avoiding the least probable risk.