Re:Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals
by TeMPOraL on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @01:46AM
(#26708317)
In its introduction, the article contrasts "being able to decide what business you deal with" with "the non-judicial punishment of individuals". I'm not a fan how it simultaneously grouped it together - it's setting the scene up for others to do motte-and-bailey defense (using the business/voting facet to defend abuse towards individuals). But even more surprisingly, the article seems to be oblivious as to why cancellation has teeth - it involves chaining these two facets together.
A bunch of Internet strangers shunning you or calling you names can be distressing, but is mostly inconsequential. The problem starts when the crowd issues or implies a threat - threat of weaponizing this "key part of having a free market" against organizations associated with the victim. Threat of amplifying a negative message to a larger crowd still, to the point it could impact a company's bottom-line, a foundation's mission. Only then the victim is being cancelled, as the groups around them cut ties to save themselves.
A bunch of Internet strangers shunning you or calling you names can be distressing, but is mostly inconsequential. The problem starts when the crowd issues or implies a threat - threat of weaponizing this "key part of having a free market" against organizations associated with the victim. Threat of amplifying a negative message to a larger crowd still, to the point it could impact a company's bottom-line, a foundation's mission. Only then the victim is being cancelled, as the groups around them cut ties to save themselves.