News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals by echelon on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @01:30AM (#26708220)
> should not get to define what freedom means.

This little bit right here sounds fascist.

I'm not going to defend RMS' words or actions (I don't even know what the entire case against him is, and the more extreme this gets the less I want to pry into his personal life). I do think people are losing their minds to assassinate the guy.

RMS has given us our entire industry and careers. Without free software, you wouldn't have a job. I wouldn't either. Take a moment and let the gravity of that sink in.

(take a moment)

He apologized and spent several years away from the organization he founded. Why does it have to be the rest of his natural life? We're murdering him and taking his baby.

Why do people nowadays believe in permanent assassination of character? Unending punishment?

People have redemption arcs.

The stupid movies, books, and tv shows that everyone in this thread watches have forgiveness and grace in them. Why do we deny them to our fellow humans?

I'm an atheist, but Jesus preached against this kind of thing, and I think we could learn from some of his teachings. Throwing stones and forgiveness.

=========================================================

I got cut off by the Hacker News negative karma filter for the downvotes I got, but I typed out a comment I was pretty happy with. (It was to this comment [2]) I'll include it here instead:

> There ought to be a place for RMS in our discourse. Just not this one.

I'm trying to think of the limit of humanity here, when we're all living in the metaverse and aren't tied to physical bodies anymore. Complete freedom, and the ability to disassociate ourselves from our corporeal bodies. Assume new identities at will.

In the future, you'd ban the "RMS account" for misbehavior, but he'd be free to join again under a new one, free from the judgments and baggage of the old account. He'd just lack all of the accolades and gear he'd built up.

What you're doing now is calling for RMS permadeath in meatspace. He can't restart. It's game over.

Since there is no ability to restart IRL lives, why don't we have forgiveness as a feature?

The US penal system has a notion of when punishments have been meted out. He's stepped down for several years. Was it not long enough of a punishment?

Are we saying that some people may never forgive RMS? And that we're restricting his access indefinitely to satisfy the people who hold grudges eternally?

What sort of bug in humanity is that?

Maybe certain people think we should stop letting people out of jail.

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26708215

Re:Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:37AM (#26708692)
> He apologized and spent several years away from the organization he founded.

September 2019 — March 2021 isn’t “several years”. Many of the othern elements of your description are similarly creative interpretations of the facts.

Re:Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals by echelon on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:29PM (#26719535)
Oh come on! That's the substantive part of my comment you're going to criticize?

That's 16 to 18 months, not far from 24. This is such a nitpick.

Why don't you address the rest of my comment?