I'll illustrate the point as such: My username is Sayter. 1) Go find my Facebook. 2) Then go find my Twitter. 3) Now go find my OpenID. You immediately know where to go for the first two, and in fact can type in the url's for my Facebook and Twitter accounts directly. But how about my OpenID? Is it my Gmail? Yahoo account? Windows Live account? All of the above? Whichever I use the most? Or is it the OpenID that I have on one my domains? My identity for OpenID is fragmented (I'm not even sure how many I have, honestly) and does not exist in a single space, while Facebook and Twitter do exist in single spaces (assuming I only have one Facebook/Twitter of course, but that possibility was simplified for the sake of argument).
That is a non-trivial problem that Facebook and Twitter have (mostly) solved, while OpenID is still struggling with it.
I'm not sure I understand what you're saying here. TTBOMK, Google, Yahoo!, and Windows Live ID are all also OpenID providers. E.g., the Isotropic online Dominion server allows users to “log in with a Google or Yahoo! account” with an OpenID backend.
So if your thesis is that people reject OpenID because they can't extend their identities from those existing accounts, I don't see how that's the case, unless the OPs have restrictions I'm unaware of. (People might not know they can identify themselves with those accounts, which I think is a real problem, but a separate one.)