News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Your Form Checkboxes Need to Have Label Tags by ars on Sunday June 19, 2011 @05:17AM (#2670610)
I've been doing this for years and have never had the slightest alignment issue. Example?

Or do you mean if the label and input are in different columns of a table - in that case, obviously split them. I'm talking when they are near each other.

And I totally disagree about the semantics. Wrapping the label is much more correct semantically - it says this input and these words are related.

I do not understand what you mean by "simpler scripting". Are you trying to make a special script action when they click the words? I wouldn't do that - make the action on the input element.

Re:Why Your Form Checkboxes Need to Have Label Tags by codingthebeach on Sunday June 19, 2011 @06:03AM (#2670657)
Per the spec, both approaches are correct.

http://www.w3.org/TR/html4/interact/forms.html#h-17.9.1

I think using an explicit "for" attribute is cleaner than bundling the control inside the label tag, as you can transparently position the label without worrying about parental boundaries. Take the typical case of a container label:

    <LABEL>
        First Name
        <INPUT type="text" name="firstname">
    </LABEL>
The problem is that when you position/style the label in your CSS, you're also (by default) positioning the inner INPUT. This is easy enough to adjust in CSS but I prefer my elements to have "honest boundaries". To me it's slightly ugly to have a container element (<label> in this case) contain a sub-element (<input> in this case), but have the sub-element drift outside the boundaries of the parent.

So I prefer my labels and their corresponding inputs to be decoupled in the sense that neither contains the other. Another (slight) advantage to this approach is that you can cleanly assign multiple labels to the same input control, though I'm not sure when you'd want or need to do so.

Re:Why Your Form Checkboxes Need to Have Label Tags by masklinn on Sunday June 19, 2011 @08:36AM (#2670750)
> And I totally disagree about the semantics. Wrapping the label is much more correct semantically - it says this input and these words are related.

No, it says the input is part of the label, which is obviously nonsense. The opposite would work, but it's not legal. The @for attribute says they are related.

> I do not understand what you mean by "simpler scripting". Are you trying to make a special script action when they click the words?

Not necessarily click, but hover for instance. What if hovering over a label gave meta-information on the related field? As I noted, getting the field matching a label (and getting *whether the label has a matching field at all) is much easier via @for, it's a trivial getElementById dereference of label/@for.