News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf] by btilly on Monday April 05, 2021 @02:41PM (#26702854)
For most circuits what you say would be true. But the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit is special. As http://www.cafc.uscourts.gov/the-court/court-jurisdiction says, their jurisdiction is national and determined by subject matter.

That said I do not actually know whether they would be binding on another circuit court. But they are definitely binding on all federal courts lower than that.

However that question is sort of moot. It is extremely easy for the entity filing the case for infringement to include something about patent or trademark in the suit, which guarantees that you wind up in the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Where that ruling is binding.

Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf] by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:40PM (#26719612)
> their jurisdiction is national and determined by subject matter.

Copyright is not part of their subject matter jurisdiction.

> However that question is sort of moot. It is extremely easy for the entity filing the case for infringement to include something about patent or trademark in the suit, which guarantees that you wind up in the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Where that ruling is binding.

It’s not, though; outside of its own subject matter jurisdiction, CAFC is bound by the law of the Circuit to which the trial court belongs, which it, in theory, merely applies. Another case coming up through the Northern District of California like Oracle v. Google did would be governed vy Ninth Circuit, not Federal Circuit, copyright precedent even if heard in the Federal Circuit because of other issues in the case.