News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf] by flumpcakes on Monday April 05, 2021 @10:31AM (#26699477)
I was under the impression that a dissent has to be written, even if they all agree in the majority opinion/ruling?
Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf] by thaumasiotes on Monday April 05, 2021 @10:35AM (#26699553)
No; in order to write a dissent, you have to disagree with the result.

If you write a separate opinion while voting with the majority, that's a "concurrence", not a dissent, and those aren't mandatory either.

Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf] by gjsman-1000 on Monday April 05, 2021 @10:33AM (#26699517)
You also forget that a justice might feel more comfortable with ruling in opposition so that he/she can write the dissent, but if his/her vote was a swing vote, the justice might have second thoughts about that. It's easy to vote in opposition when you know it doesn't matter - and then, hey, you get to write the position for the losing side.
Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf] by thaumasiotes on Monday April 05, 2021 @10:38AM (#26699586)
> You also forget that a justice might feel more comfortable with ruling in opposition so that he/she can write the dissent, but if his/her vote was a swing vote, the justice might have second thoughts about that.

This doesn't make any sense. Justices vote in the majority while disagreeing with part or all of the majority opinion all the time. The mechanism for complaining about the majority reasoning is the same in either case: you write a separate opinion detailing your personal analysis of the case. That opinion is called a "dissent" if you voted against the majority and a "concurrence" if you voted with the majority.

There is no concept of "the dissent". Any dissenting justice is free to write one; it is routine for one case to have multiple dissents.

Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf] by KerrickStaley on Monday April 05, 2021 @10:35AM (#26699542)
No, a dissent means that one or more of the judges disagreed with the majority ruling.