News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by tinco on Monday April 05, 2021 @04:03AM (#26696412)
This is due to the method of data acquisition. My company also uses cesium (in the browser) for visualization at sub cm level for inspection. Our quality bar is that inspectors have to be able to inspect the grain of the grout between the bricks.

We acquire the data in 3 modes for high buildings, we do low altitude fly over with the 2m drone, then we do facade with the regular drone, and finally we shoot from the ground. We only do ground based lidar, but aerial lidar is improving so maybe that's next. The rest is all high detail photos fed into photogrammetry.

The final results look perfect in cesium, some thin rails might not show up, and windows get a bit funky, but the geometry and the textures load in without a hitch, really cool technology that's so simple in the basis that we built an alternative viewer in Rust+WASM in 3 weeks.

Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by X6S1x6Okd1st on Monday April 05, 2021 @10:00AM (#26699058)
Could you use a technique like this to do facade inspection as mandated in nyc?

I just happened to watch "how to with John Wilson" S01E02 which was talking about how scaffolding is put up everywhere in nyc because the facade needs to be inspected for loose bricks every 5 years

Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by StavrosK on Monday April 05, 2021 @05:15AM (#26696844)
Wait, if the technology is so simple that you can build an alternative viewer in 3 weeks, what are they selling? Is it the data format?
Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by tinco on Monday April 05, 2021 @09:13AM (#26698474)
They've got a whole bunch of features in their viewer, making a feature matching viewer would take years. The basic technology is a tree of JSON files describing what models or other JSON files to load for regions of space. So the nodes are JSON files and the leaves are 3d models basically. There's a simple algorithm that you give your current perspective (i.e. where you are in space, and what direction you're looking in) that will walk the tree and decide what models will be in your field of view and which won't be, and at what distance (which decides the level of detail). Then the last step is simply downloading those models, while at the same time evicting irrelevant 3d models from your gpu.

They hand rolled an entire high performance 3D engine in Javascript, which is a big challenge in and of itself. We cheated by using WASM and a high performance programming language, making the 3D engine part trivial. Likewise, I'd be surprised if it took them more than a week or two to get their initial proof of concept working in Unreal Engine.

Oh and I believe their business model is/was to sell hosting and processing for the 3D models. We've been paying them a couple hundred per month just for this service.

Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by StavrosK on Monday April 05, 2021 @09:20AM (#26698551)
That's helpful, thank you!
Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by sbarre on Monday April 05, 2021 @08:05AM (#26697921)
3 weeks for a prototype

3 months for an alpha

3 quarters for a production release.

You know how engineering estimates work... ;-)

Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by asutekku on Monday April 05, 2021 @07:17AM (#26697591)
They’re selling it so you don’t have to get it by yourself.
Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by maxhq on Monday April 05, 2021 @05:49AM (#26697059)
Off topic, but: would you mind telling which software you are using for the photogrammetry?
Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by tinco on Monday April 05, 2021 @09:06AM (#26698406)
We're using Metashape and Reality Capture. We used to use Bentley, but they've got unethical business practices so we're avoiding them now.

Metashape has really good licensing, and their software runs on Linux and is easy to integrate into processing pipelines, also they've got a big featureset.

Reality Capture was super expensive, though that has seemingly changed now that they're bought by Epic, so we might reconsider our strategy there. They make better use of hardware, making them faster, and their resulting models look great. Their licensing was so expensive that we just couldn't afford switching all of our processing to RC.

Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by andybak on Monday April 05, 2021 @12:59PM (#26701542)
> We used to use Bentley, but they've got unethical business practices

Go on. I'm curious now.

Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by tinco on Monday April 05, 2021 @01:39PM (#26702012)
You can google a bit about Bentley Connect charges, we were not the only ones who called their sales reps in a panic.

https://community.spiceworks.com/topic/2129583-gathering-inf...

If you can get a good deal with them it's probably fine, and we only talked to nice people there. But we're still on limited runway, we can't deal with random $20k invoices, even if a nice sales rep reverts the charge when called.

Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by reactive001 on Monday April 05, 2021 @07:56AM (#26697858)
Having worked at a company with an identical premise, Reality Capture (because it's faster) or Bentleys
Re:Cesium for Unreal Now Available by tinco on Monday April 05, 2021 @09:07AM (#26698408)
Nice! where did you work?