If I feel you brought something on yourself why would I help you and not an innocent victim? And how would charity help resolve the issue of you dumping the cost on others, it would just be me instead of all of us, but still subsidizing.
> It would clearly be a moral obscenity to systematically allow people to die of treatable diseases because they can't afford treatment.
No, only if that money couldn't do greater good elsewhere.
> And if it's a question of 'blame' or 'risky behavior', then we should be refusing treatment to anyone who's ever eaten a donut.
In some proportion to the number of donuts, yes. Of course. Or at least they should go to the back of the line after we've helped people who didn't self-inflict.
> how would charity help resolve the issue of you dumping the cost on others
OP objected to others being forced to pay. Charity is voluntary.
> Or at least they should go to the back of the line
What would this even mean in the case of the US. About 35% of adults are obese, and in almost all instances that’s due to their behavioral choices. Do we send a third of the population “to the back of the line”, or refuse to pay for their medical treatment?
The fact that you call my initial exposition "despicable" reminds me that HN isn't a good forum for this kind of discussion.
I regret posting a comment that elicited this kind of discussion.
The proposal that you’re hinting at is very far outside the mainstream. I don’t think you’re likely to find any forum (that you’d want to be a part of) where it doesn’t elicit a strong negative reaction.
HN is probably one of few places that tolerates this kind of extremism enough to at least engage with your argument (such as it is) rather than just telling you to get stuffed.
No, only help people if they didn't bring it on themselves and would probably be able to receive the help. There's no sense wasting a bunch of help on a junkie who won't use it, but once he's off the smack and willing to receive help then maybe. But only if a needy mother's kids don't need it more.
> Charity is voluntary.
Right, but you present it as an obligation. These people aren't being funded so you could just do it yourselves.
> About 35% of adults are obese, and in almost all instances that’s due to their behavioral choices. Do we send a third of the population “to the back of the line”, or refuse to pay for their medical treatment?
Oh boy, you're gonna hate this. Yes. And we already do. Try asking for an organ while you're a smoker. They give that sucker to someone who can use it and will take care of it.
What misguided sense of honor could force you to dispense treatment in the order people arrived in versus their need/ability to receive?
You're suggesting that this is what Christianity has to say on the subject of charity?
>Right, but you present [charity] as an obligation.
No, I didn't. I pointed out that voluntary charitable contributions would be a good way to resolve the tension that the OP feels between 'justice' and 'mercy'.
>Oh boy, you're gonna hate this. Yes. And we already do.
In the case of organs there's an inherently limited supply, since people have to donate voluntarily and all sorts of other conditions have to be met. It's not as if we're throwing away livers rather than give them to alcoholics.
I'm sure you must be aware that we do treat all kinds of obesity-related conditions – and at great expense. In the case of HIV treatment, it's largely just a question of paying for drugs which can easily be manufactured in the required quantity.
But I guess at this point I'm wondering what your actual position is. Are you in favor of conditionally refusing treatment to HIV patients depending on the manner in which they contracted the virus? If so, why not just come out and say it? And if not, what exactly are you getting at?
Yes, and charity spending on one person necessarily takes away from spending on another too. To support someone whose choice of behavior impacted them means you can't support someone who was injured entirely through 'acts of god'.
> It's not as if we're throwing away livers rather than give them to alcoholics.
No, but but they do go to the back of the line. Especially if they still drink.
> I'm sure you must be aware that we do treat all kinds of obesity-related conditions – and at great expense.
Sure. But thankfully we prioritize them to below children with heart defects, and non-obese adults with the same conditions.
> Are you in favor of conditionally refusing treatment to HIV patients depending on the manner in which they contracted the virus?
No more than I am for prioritizing treatment downward for everyone whose injuries were self-inflicted. That's only fair for the people whose were not.
As to the rest, you're obviously aware that in general, obese adults are not deprioritized for treatment as compared to non-obese adults.
That's pretty much a textbook example of sealioning. Why are you so anxious?
> HIV
Are they asking for charity? If not then their circumstances shouldn't be relevant, just their ability to pay.
> you're obviously aware that in general, obese adults are not deprioritized for treatment as compared to non-obese adults.
They are. If you're up for a contested treatment (a rare organ, a diagnostic machine that's always in use) you're given a score that represents your health and ability to benefit. Obesity isn't a total black mark but it absolutely is considered. However, we don't consider why you're fat, fat is just a health risk and we recognize that and don't waste effort where it won't be rewarded.
We already covered the special case of contested treatments. It’s obviously irrelevant here as we are just talking about access to drugs for HIV patients, not access to an inherently limited resource. Either you pay for Truvda or you don’t. There’s no queue.
Similarly, if you are obese, no generally available treatment that could be of medical benefit to you will be denied merely because it’s expensive and you’re obese.
Nope. There's a limit to everyone's insurance, beyond which they will not pay for more treatment. You won't get told that you're too fat but your treatments will cost more and consequently you'll get less of them. Your insurance contract is for a sum of money, not a specific set of life-saving actions.
But generally that limit is much higher than what you've paid so your expensive treatments take money from the pool.
> there is no ethical dilemma in insurers paying for HIV treatment regardless of whether the patient acted irresponsibly.
As long as their fees cover the payments. But if they're costing more than they're paying as a class, meaning that all other users are compensating them, then yes - dilemma.
> It’s obviously irrelevant here as we are just talking about access to drugs for HIV patients, not access to an inherently limited resource. Either you pay for Truvda or you don’t. There’s no queue.
Paying out of your own pocket, 100% fine regardless.
I was disheartened to have shared my inner conflict on the issue, only to be downvoted into oblivion.
Perhaps one of my mistakes was using HIV as an example. If someone only skimmed my post, they may have pattern-matched on the whole "AIDS is punishment from God" trope, which is 100% not what I was trying to say.
Oddly enough, despite being so deeply concerned with mercy and justice, religious conservatives do not appear to be among the leading donors to HIV-related charities.
That said, I don't see any kind of ethical dilemma here at all. It would clearly be a moral obscenity to systematically allow people to die of treatable diseases because they can't afford treatment. And if it's a question of 'blame' or 'risky behavior', then we should be refusing treatment to anyone who's ever eaten a donut.